Deneffe G, Lacquet L M, Gyselen A
Eur J Respir Dis. 1983 Nov;64(8):613-9.
In the period 1975-1980, 1504 patients presented with lung cancer, 291 were presumably operable, and had no radiological evidence of mediastinal lymph node invasion. Two thirds (192 patients) underwent pre-operative surgical mediastinal exploration, and one third (99 patients) were operated right away. Of the 162 cervical mediastinoscopies, 16% had lymph node invasion (19.7% with right-sided, 10.6% with left-sided tumor); 28.9% of the 45 left-anterior mediastinotomies were positive. There was only one positive cervical mediastinoscopy of 46 cases with lower-lobe tumor, and no positive anterior mediastinotomy in 5 cases with left lower-lobe tumor. Mediastinal exploration yields, thus, a relatively higher percentage of positive results if the cervical mediastinoscopy is restricted to tumors affecting the right upper and middle lobes (25%), and if the anterior mediastinotomy is restricted to the left upper lobe (32.5%). A left anterior mediastinotomy should, thus, be recommended instead of cervical mediastinoscopy for tumors of the left upper lobe.
在1975年至1980年期间,1504例患者被诊断为肺癌,其中291例可能适合手术,且无纵隔淋巴结转移的影像学证据。三分之二(192例患者)接受了术前纵隔探查手术,三分之一(99例患者)直接进行了手术。在162例颈部纵隔镜检查中,16%存在淋巴结转移(右侧肿瘤为19.7%,左侧肿瘤为10.6%);45例左前纵隔切开术中,28.9%为阳性。46例下叶肿瘤患者中,颈部纵隔镜检查仅1例阳性,5例左下叶肿瘤患者中,前纵隔切开术均无阳性结果。因此,如果颈部纵隔镜检查仅限于影响右上叶和中叶的肿瘤(25%),且前纵隔切开术仅限于左上叶(32.5%),纵隔探查的阳性结果比例相对较高。因此,对于左上叶肿瘤,应推荐采用左前纵隔切开术而非颈部纵隔镜检查。