Chilvers C
Int J Epidemiol. 1983 Dec;12(4):397-404. doi: 10.1093/ije/12.4.397.
The possibility of a cancer risk associated with fluoridation of public water supplies is re-examined using mortality data for 35 US cities, 20 with fluoridated water supplies and 15 with non-fluoridated water. Crude cancer death rates, and mortality ratios standardized for age, sex, and ethnic group are examined, using four alternative sets of standard rates and three different combinations of pericensal years' deaths. Changes in cancer mortality before and after fluoridation in the fluoridated cities are compared with changes in the non-fluoridated cities over the same time period. In none of the analyses have differences in mortality trends been found that could not be due to chance alone. Thus, these results do not support the suggestion of an association between fluoridation of water supplies and cancer mortality.
利用美国35个城市的死亡率数据,重新审视了公共供水氟化与癌症风险之间的关联可能性。其中20个城市的供水进行了氟化处理,15个城市的供水未进行氟化处理。使用四组不同的标准率和三年死亡数据的三种不同组合,对粗癌症死亡率以及按年龄、性别和种族标准化的死亡率进行了研究。将氟化处理城市氟化前后的癌症死亡率变化与同期未氟化处理城市的变化进行了比较。在所有分析中,均未发现死亡率趋势存在不能仅归因于偶然因素的差异。因此,这些结果不支持供水氟化与癌症死亡率之间存在关联的说法。