Main D M, Main E K, Maurer M M
Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1983 Jul 1;146(5):580-4. doi: 10.1016/0002-9378(83)90807-4.
Although previous studies have suggested that the breech infant weighing less than 1,500 gm benefits from cesarean section, the published results have not demonstrated statistically significant differences. We have evaluated pediatric outcome data for 240 breech infants and 525 vertex infants who weighed less than 1,500 gm, to determine whether route of delivery affects infant morbidity and mortality. Twenty-nine percent of these very small breech infants who were delivered by cesarean section died, as compared to 58% of breech infants of similar weight who were delivered vaginally (p less than 0.001). Comparable significant differences were found for the infants delivered at a university hospital as well as for those delivered at a group of nonuniversity hospitals. Apgar scores and the incidence and severity of intraventricular hemorrhage were not different for the cesarean section and vaginally delivered breech infants. Furthermore, the survival rate of the breech infants delivered by cesarean section equaled that of the vertex infants delivered either by cesarean section or vaginally.
尽管先前的研究表明,体重不足1500克的臀位婴儿可从剖宫产中获益,但已发表的结果并未显示出统计学上的显著差异。我们评估了240例体重不足1500克的臀位婴儿和525例体重不足1500克的头位婴儿的儿科结局数据,以确定分娩方式是否会影响婴儿的发病率和死亡率。这些体重极轻的臀位婴儿中,29%通过剖宫产分娩后死亡,而体重相似的臀位婴儿经阴道分娩的死亡率为58%(p<0.001)。在大学医院分娩的婴儿以及在一组非大学医院分娩的婴儿中也发现了类似的显著差异。剖宫产和经阴道分娩的臀位婴儿的阿氏评分以及脑室内出血的发生率和严重程度并无差异。此外,剖宫产分娩的臀位婴儿的存活率与剖宫产或经阴道分娩的头位婴儿的存活率相当。