Pearl G S, Check I J, Hunter R L
Am J Clin Pathol. 1984 May;81(5):575-80. doi: 10.1093/ajcp/81.5.575.
The cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) IgG index, the CSF to serum albumin ratio, and electrophoresis on agarose gel of CSF and serum were evaluated retrospectively for their usefulness in the differential diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS). Standardized procedures were adopted for grading the intensity of oligoclonal banding and for the certainty of diagnosis of MS. One hundred and forty-nine patients were studied, including 23 with definite multiple sclerosis (MS), 12 with probable MS, 20 with possible MS, 20 with inflammatory neurologic disease, 65 with noninflammatory neurologic disease, and nine with no neurologic disease. The CSF IgG index and the CSF to serum albumin ratio were calculated from nephelometric measurements of serum and CSF IgG and albumin. The intensity of oligoclonal banding was graded relative to the density of the prealbumin band. Eighty-eight per cent of cases of definite MS had distinct oligoclonal bands, and an equal number had an elevated IgG index. These tests were not specific for MS, however, since 50% of cases of inflammatory neurologic disease and 5% of those with noninflammatory neurologic disease had an elevated IgG index. Similarly, 48% of cases with inflammatory disease and 25% with noninflammatory disease had oligoclonal bands. However, only patients with definite MS (21%) or possible MS (4%) had prominent oligoclonal bands whose density was greater than or equal to that of prealbumin, together with a CSF IgG index greater than 1.50. This combination of findings therefore may enhance the level of suspicion of MS. By contrast, an isolated increase in the CSF to serum albumin ratio may suggest a diagnosis other than MS.
对脑脊液(CSF)IgG指数、脑脊液与血清白蛋白比值以及脑脊液和血清的琼脂糖凝胶电泳进行回顾性评估,以确定其在多发性硬化症(MS)鉴别诊断中的作用。采用标准化程序对寡克隆带强度进行分级,并确定MS诊断的确定性。共研究了149例患者,包括23例确诊为多发性硬化症(MS)、12例可能为MS、20例可能为MS、20例患有炎性神经系统疾病、65例患有非炎性神经系统疾病以及9例无神经系统疾病。脑脊液IgG指数和脑脊液与血清白蛋白比值通过血清和脑脊液IgG及白蛋白的散射比浊法测量计算得出。寡克隆带强度相对于前白蛋白带的密度进行分级。88%的确诊MS病例有明显的寡克隆带,且相同比例的病例IgG指数升高。然而,这些检查并非MS所特有,因为50%的炎性神经系统疾病病例和5%的非炎性神经系统疾病病例IgG指数升高。同样,48%的炎性疾病病例和25%的非炎性疾病病例有寡克隆带。然而,只有确诊为MS的患者(21%)或可能为MS的患者(4%)有突出的寡克隆带,其密度大于或等于前白蛋白,且脑脊液IgG指数大于1.50。因此,这种综合发现可能会提高对MS的怀疑程度。相比之下,脑脊液与血清白蛋白比值单独升高可能提示除MS以外的其他诊断。