Schutte J E, Townsend E J, Hugg J, Shoup R F, Malina R M, Blomqvist C G
J Appl Physiol Respir Environ Exerc Physiol. 1984 Jun;56(6):1647-9. doi: 10.1152/jappl.1984.56.6.1647.
Previous studies have reported that Blacks have 10-20% more bone mineral than Whites of the same height. Theoretically, this should mean that the lean body mass of Blacks is denser than that of Whites, such that formulas for calculating lean body mass from density in Whites will overestimate the lean body mass (and thus underestimate fatness) in Blacks. To determine if the lean body mass of Blacks is indeed denser than that of Whites, we measured density, total body water, and anthropometric dimensions in 19 white and 15 black male college students. The black and white cohorts were nearly identical in height, weight, and total body water. Among the Whites there was no significant difference between the observed density and that predicted from anthropometry, nor were there any significant differences between the dimensions of body composition calculated from total body water and from observed density. Among the Blacks, however, the observed density was significantly greater than that predicted from anthropometry, and the lean body mass calculated from observed density was significantly greater than that calculated from total body water. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the lean body mass of the Blacks is denser than that of the Whites. Separate formulas should therefore be used for converting density to body composition. Based on our data, the correct formula for Blacks is: %fat = 100 X [(4.374/density) - 3.928]. This formula indicates a lean body density of 1.113 g/cm3 in Blacks compared with 1.100 in Whites.
先前的研究报告称,身高相同的黑人比白人的骨矿物质多10%至20%。从理论上讲,这意味着黑人的瘦体重比白人的更致密,因此,根据白人密度计算瘦体重的公式会高估黑人的瘦体重(从而低估肥胖程度)。为了确定黑人的瘦体重是否确实比白人的更致密,我们测量了19名白人男大学生和15名黑人男大学生的密度、全身水含量和人体测量尺寸。黑人和白人两组在身高、体重和全身水含量方面几乎相同。在白人中,观察到的密度与根据人体测量学预测的密度之间没有显著差异,根据全身水含量和观察到的密度计算出的身体成分维度之间也没有显著差异。然而,在黑人中,观察到的密度显著高于根据人体测量学预测的密度,根据观察到的密度计算出的瘦体重显著高于根据全身水含量计算出的瘦体重。这些结果与黑人的瘦体重比白人的更致密这一假设一致。因此,应该使用不同的公式将密度转换为身体成分。根据我们的数据,适用于黑人的正确公式是:%脂肪 = 100×[(4.374/密度) - 3.928]。该公式表明,黑人的瘦体密度为1.113克/立方厘米,而白人的为1.100克/立方厘米。