Simonet W T, Sim F H
Am J Sports Med. 1984 Mar-Apr;12(2):89-97. doi: 10.1177/036354658401200201.
We studied the results of treatment in 110 of 129 consecutive patients who had knee instability for which they underwent reconstruction of the knee ligaments at the Mayo Clinic. Thirty-one patients underwent different types of extraarticular reconstruction. Nine (29%) had recurrence of the knee giving way, and 11 (36%) had objective signs of instability on examination. Fifty-five patients underwent combined extraarticular and intraarticular reconstruction with either the Lam-Jones patellar tendon (PT) procedure (21 knees) or the Zarins-Rowe semitendinosus and iliotibial band (ST & ITB) procedure (34 knees). Only two knees (10%) with PT procedure and three knees (9%) with ST & ITB procedures continued to have giving way. Three patients in each group had recurrence of instability. Twenty-four knees with acute instability had either primary repair (17 knees) or primary reconstruction with ST & ITB procedures (7 knees). The results in these knees were superior to the results in the knees reconstructed for chronic instability. On the basis of our 2 year results, we believe that a combined intraarticular and extraarticular reconstruction is the procedure of choice in chronic knee instability and is a useful procedure in acute knee instability with irreparable tears of the anterior cruciate ligament.
我们研究了梅奥诊所连续129例因膝关节不稳定而接受膝关节韧带重建手术患者中的110例的治疗结果。31例患者接受了不同类型的关节外重建。其中9例(29%)出现膝关节打软复发,11例(36%)在检查时有客观的不稳定体征。55例患者接受了关节外和关节内联合重建,其中21例采用Lam-Jones髌腱(PT)手术,34例采用Zarins-Rowe半腱肌和髂胫束(ST & ITB)手术。采用PT手术的患者中只有2例(10%)、采用ST & ITB手术的患者中有3例(9%)继续存在膝关节打软。每组各有3例患者出现不稳定复发。24例急性不稳定的膝关节患者接受了一期修复(17例)或采用ST & ITB手术进行一期重建(7例)。这些膝关节的治疗结果优于因慢性不稳定而进行重建的膝关节。根据我们两年的研究结果,我们认为关节内和关节外联合重建是慢性膝关节不稳定的首选治疗方法,对于前交叉韧带不可修复性撕裂的急性膝关节不稳定也是一种有效的治疗方法。