Branson D R
Environ Health Perspect. 1980 Feb;34:133-8. doi: 10.1289/ehp.8034133.
Chemicals designated as "priority pollutants" or "toxics" have received special attention recently because the discharge of these compounds into public water is to be restricted to the maximum possible with little regard to water quality or economics. The selection of many of the 129 priority cemicals was not based on an objective scientific assessment of the exposure and effect data. In fact, for some compounds, including acenaphthene and 4-chlorophenyl-phenyl ether, the necessary data for listing were non-existent. As an alternative to arbitrarily listing or delisting chemicals for the purpose of prioity control, this paper suggests a promising scientific approach to selecting priority chemicals based on the principles of hazard assessment for chemicals in the aquatic environment. According o the hypothesis, the highest priority chemicals are those with the least margin of safety, defined as the gap between the no-observable-effect concentrations and the ambient exposure concentrations. The no-observable-effect concenrations are based on the results of chronic or sensitive life stage tests with aquatic organisms and the acceptable daily intake rate for fish eates. The ambient exposure concentrations are levels either measured in fish and water, or roughly estimated from a simple nomogram that requires only two of the following three factors: environmental release rate, ratio of dissipation to bioconcentration potential, or ambient residues in fish. THE CHEMICALS STUDIED TO ILLUSTRATE THIS APPROACH TO PRIORITIZING CHEMICALS BASED ON HAZARD ASSESSMENT ARE: polychlorinated biphenyls, di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate, linear alkylbenzene sulfonate, and pentachlorophenol.
被指定为“优先污染物”或“有毒物质”的化学品最近受到了特别关注,因为这些化合物向公共水体中的排放将被尽可能地限制,而很少考虑水质或经济因素。129种优先化学品中许多的选定并非基于对暴露和影响数据的客观科学评估。事实上,对于一些化合物,包括苊和4-氯苯基苯基醚,列入清单所需的数据并不存在。作为为优先控制目的而随意列出或删除化学品的替代方法,本文提出了一种基于水生环境中化学品危害评估原则来选择优先化学品的有前景的科学方法。根据该假设,优先级最高的化学品是那些安全边际最小的化学品,安全边际定义为无观测效应浓度与环境暴露浓度之间的差距。无观测效应浓度基于对水生生物进行的慢性或敏感生命阶段测试结果以及鱼类食用者的每日可接受摄入量。环境暴露浓度是在鱼类和水中测量的水平,或者根据一个简单的列线图大致估算,该列线图仅需要以下三个因素中的两个:环境释放率、消散与生物富集潜力的比率或鱼类中的环境残留量。为说明这种基于危害评估对化学品进行优先排序方法而研究的化学品有:多氯联苯、邻苯二甲酸二(2-乙基己基)酯、直链烷基苯磺酸盐和五氯酚。