Starkey I R, Lawson A A
Q J Med. 1980 Winter;49(193):33-49.
Self-poisoning with tricyclic and related anti-depressant drugs has increased in frequency over the last few years so that, at present, some 20 per cent of patients admitted to hospital following self-poisoning have ingested a drug of this group, either alone or, more commonly, in association with alcohol, a benzodiazepine and/or other drugs. We present the results of a retrospective analysis of 316 admissions to a general medical hospital dealing with patients over 12 years, following self-poisoning with tricylic or related drugs. Although serious toxic effects may sometimes occur, their frequency has probably been over-estimated, at least in older children and adults; in this series the incidence of significant hypotension was 13 per cent, grand mal convulsions 4 per cent, respiratory depression to the degree of requiring mechanical ventilation 2 per cent and severe cardiac arrhythmias or conduction disturbances 1.5 per cent. It is suggested that routine 'prophylactic' treatment against convulsions and cardiac arrhythmias, advocated by some previous authors, is unnecessary and potentially dangerous; indeed, even the establishment of an intravenous infusion may put an extra strain on a depressed myocardium. In this series, supportive treatment alone was sufficient for the majority of patients (81.6 per cent) and additional treatment was given only in the presence of some specific indication. Using such conservative measures, the mortality rate in the 10-year study was only 0.6 per cent. Medical efforts in the future, it is suggested, would be more appropriately directed towards preventing unnecessary prescribing of these drugs for trivial mental upset, rather than the development of new drugs of this type or other 'prophylactic' measures, designed to prevent relatively rare toxic effects.
在过去几年中,三环类及相关抗抑郁药物的自我中毒事件愈发频繁。目前,因自我中毒而入院的患者中,约20%摄入了此类药物,这些患者要么单独服用了该类药物,要么(更常见的情况是)同时摄入了酒精、苯二氮䓬类药物和/或其他药物。我们对一家综合医院收治的316例12岁以上因三环类或相关药物自我中毒的患者进行了回顾性分析,并呈现分析结果。尽管有时可能会出现严重的毒性作用,但至少在大龄儿童和成年人中,其发生频率可能被高估了;在本系列病例中,显著低血压的发生率为13%,癫痫大发作的发生率为4%,需要机械通气程度的呼吸抑制发生率为2%,严重心律失常或传导障碍的发生率为1.5%。有观点认为,先前一些作者所倡导的针对惊厥和心律失常的常规“预防性”治疗既无必要,还可能存在危险;事实上,即便建立静脉输液也可能给功能不全的心肌增加额外负担。在本系列病例中,对于大多数患者(81.6%)而言,仅采取支持性治疗就足够了,只有在出现某些特定指征时才给予额外治疗。采用这种保守措施后,在为期10年的研究中,死亡率仅为0.6%。有人认为,未来的医疗工作应更适当地致力于防止因轻微精神不适而不必要地开具这些药物,而非研发此类新药或采取其他旨在预防相对罕见毒性作用的“预防性”措施。