Rustin L, Kuhr A, Cook P J, James I M
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1981 Aug 22;283(6290):517-9. doi: 10.1136/bmj.283.6290.517.
In a controlled trial of treatment for stammering under stress oxprenolol (40 mg) compared with placebo was assessed in a double-blind manner over two days, six weeks apart, in 31 stammerers before and after speech therapy. The trial design also allowed six weeks of intensive speech therapy, using a slowed-speech and relaxation technique, to be compared with not treatment and assessed single-blind. Oxprenolol produced a significant fall in pulse rate and systolic blood pressure but no overall change in performance either before or after speech therapy. Intensive speech therapy produced a highly significant improvement in the global performance of untrained subjects (p less than 0.001) and a significant reduction in the number (p less than 0.001) and duration (p less than 0.001) of blocks. Maintenance speech therapy tended to produce further improvement in trained subjects. Speech therapy is apparently an effective treatment for stammering, whereas oxprenolol appears to be of no value when given routinely; oxprenolol may be of value, however, in very stressful conditions.
在一项针对压力下口吃治疗的对照试验中,在31名口吃者接受言语治疗前后,以双盲方式对氧烯洛尔(40毫克)与安慰剂进行了为期两天、间隔六周的评估。试验设计还允许将使用慢语速和放松技巧的六周强化言语治疗与不治疗进行比较,并采用单盲评估。氧烯洛尔使脉搏率和收缩压显著下降,但在言语治疗前后的表现总体上没有变化。强化言语治疗使未经训练的受试者的整体表现有高度显著改善(p<0.001),并使卡顿次数(p<0.001)和卡顿持续时间(p<0.001)显著减少。维持性言语治疗往往会使受过训练的受试者有进一步改善。言语治疗显然是治疗口吃的有效方法,而常规服用氧烯洛尔似乎没有价值;然而,在压力极大的情况下,氧烯洛尔可能有价值。