Kirshner L A
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1982 Jan;170(1):27-33. doi: 10.1097/00005053-198201000-00005.
In this paper, length of stay for psychiatric inpatients (LOS) is discussed in terms of controlled studies of hospitalization, research on patient factors contributing to LOS, and variation in mean or median LOS between institutions and within units. Although the multiplicity of variables involved precludes ready generalization, it can be said that open-ended hospital stays, above 28 days, have not been demonstrated to improve outcomes. However, the complexity of specific circumstances makes it unrealistic to impose rigid uniform standards within or across units. Medically managed units with a director as the locus of decision making may be in a better position to control LOS. Research into relationships between different treatment milieus and outcomes for specific diagnoses is suggested as a promising avenue for further research into cost effectiveness of hospitalization.
本文从住院治疗的对照研究、对影响住院时间的患者因素的研究,以及不同机构和单位内部平均或中位数住院时间的差异等方面,探讨了精神科住院患者的住院时间(LOS)。尽管涉及的变量众多,难以轻易进行概括,但可以说,超过28天的开放式住院治疗并未被证明能改善治疗效果。然而,具体情况的复杂性使得在单位内部或单位之间强行实施严格统一的标准并不现实。以主任作为决策核心的医疗管理单位可能更有能力控制住院时间。建议对不同治疗环境与特定诊断的治疗效果之间的关系进行研究,这是进一步研究住院治疗成本效益的一个有前景的途径。