Jaeger P, Bischoff-Delaloye A, Burckhardt P
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1981 Dec 5;111(49):1893-7.
To avoid the inhibitory effect of EHDP on bone mineralization, a variety of diphosphonates (Cl2MDP, APD) and a combination of EHDP with calcitonin have been used in the treatment of Paget's disease. In the present study, 13 patients received combined treatment with synthetic human calcitonin (HCT 0.5 mg s.c./day, 5--7 days per week) and EHDP (7.5 mg/kg, day, p.o.) for a mean duration of 6.1 months until disappearance of the symptoms. Results were compared with those obtained in a group of 10 patients treated with HCT alone. The clinical and biochemical effects were similar in both groups, although patients on the combined treatment were treated for a shorter period of time (6.1 vs 11.5 months, p less than 0.01). The desired clinical benefit was obtained within the first few months (4.9 +/- 0.9) in the group on the combined treatment, and within 8.7 +/- 2.4 months (p = 0.05) in the HCT group. Although the incidence of biochemical and scintigraphic relapse was higher than reported in the literature, no clinical recurrence has been observed up to 15 months after interruption of the combined treatment. This positive result casts doubt on the relevance of prolonged treatment of Paget's disease with HCT alone or in combination with EHDP, especially in elderly patients.
为避免依替膦酸二钠(EHDP)对骨矿化的抑制作用,多种双膦酸盐(氯甲双膦酸盐、阿仑膦酸钠)以及EHDP与降钙素的联合用药已被用于治疗佩吉特病。在本研究中,13例患者接受了合成人降钙素(HCT,0.5mg皮下注射/天,每周5 - 7天)与EHDP(7.5mg/kg,口服)的联合治疗,平均疗程为6.1个月,直至症状消失。将结果与一组仅接受HCT治疗的10例患者的结果进行比较。两组的临床和生化效果相似,尽管联合治疗组的患者治疗时间较短(6.1个月对11.5个月,p<0.01)。联合治疗组在最初几个月(4.9±0.9个月)内获得了预期的临床益处,而HCT组在8.7±2.4个月内获得(p = 0.05)。尽管生化和骨闪烁显像复发的发生率高于文献报道,但在联合治疗中断后长达15个月未观察到临床复发。这一阳性结果使人对单独使用HCT或HCT与EHDP联合长期治疗佩吉特病的相关性产生怀疑,尤其是在老年患者中。