Zung W W, Magill M, Moore J T, George D T
J Clin Psychiatry. 1983 Jan;44(1):3-6.
To test the hypothesis that depression is significantly underdiagnosed in general medical settings, the Zung Self-Rating Depression Scale was administered to 1,086 family medicine outpatients seen during a 12-month period before their initial medical examination. The effects of such screening on clinical recognition and treatment of depression were examined. Of the 1,086 patients, 143 (13.2%) were symptomatically depressed. These patients were randomized into two groups: 102 were identified as clinically depressed to their physician, and the remaining 41 were not (control group). Physicians diagnosed depression in 15% of the control group and in 68% of the identified group. At 4-week follow-up, 64% of the identified patients who were treated with maprotiline (16 of 25) showed improvement; only 28% of the identified patients who were electively not treated improved. Improvement occurred in only 18% of the control group. It appears that the diagnosis of depression is not ordinarily made in family medicine outpatient settings and that self-rating depression scales are useful diagnostic aids, whose regular use is indicated by the high prevalence of depression in general medical populations.
为了验证在普通医疗环境中抑郁症存在显著漏诊这一假设,对1086名在初次体检前12个月内就诊的家庭医学门诊患者进行了zung自评抑郁量表测试。研究了这种筛查对抑郁症临床识别和治疗的影响。在这1086名患者中,143名(13.2%)有抑郁症状。这些患者被随机分为两组:1组102名被医生确诊为临床抑郁症患者,其余41名未被确诊(对照组)。医生在对照组中诊断出抑郁症的比例为15%,在确诊组中为68%。在4周的随访中,接受马普替林治疗的确诊患者中有64%(25名中的16名)病情好转;未接受治疗的确诊患者中只有28%病情好转。对照组中只有18%的患者病情好转。看来在家庭医学门诊环境中通常不会对抑郁症进行诊断,自评抑郁量表是有用的诊断辅助工具,鉴于普通医疗人群中抑郁症的高患病率,建议定期使用。