Tcheng-Laroche F, Prince R
Soc Sci Med. 1983;17(2):95-105. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(83)90360-x.
A stratified sample of 31 French-Canadian and 33 English-Canadian separated or divorced (S/D) mothers and matched married controls were identified by telephone in four high-income census tracts of Montreal. The 128 women were home-interviewed by questionnaire which included extensive sections on health, stress and life satisfaction. It was predicted that modern S/D women with children would be better off as regards satisfaction, stress and health than pre-women's liberation era women, and that they would be as well or better off than the married controls. These hypotheses were supported only in part. The S/D were significantly worse off than the married in four areas (general life satisfaction, sexual satisfaction, self-esteem and use of professional therapists) and on almost all other health-stress measures, there were trends favouring the married. There were no significant differences or no trends favouring the S/D. Nonetheless, the S/D did appear to be considerably better off when compared with the picture of the S/D in the earlier literature. The greater frequency of depressions and greater use of therapists by the English-Canadian women was thought to reflect their weaker network of supportive relatives as well as the impact of recent political changes in Quebec.
在蒙特利尔的四个高收入普查区,通过电话确定了31名法裔加拿大和33名英裔加拿大分居或离异(S/D)母亲以及与之匹配的已婚对照者的分层样本。这128名女性接受了问卷调查的上门访谈,问卷包含关于健康、压力和生活满意度的广泛内容。据预测,有孩子的现代分居或离异女性在满意度、压力和健康方面会比女性解放运动前的女性状况更好,并且她们的状况会与已婚对照者一样好或更好。这些假设仅部分得到支持。分居或离异女性在四个方面(总体生活满意度、性满意度、自尊和使用专业治疗师)明显比已婚女性状况更差,并且在几乎所有其他健康压力指标上,都有倾向于已婚女性的趋势。没有显著差异或倾向于分居或离异女性的趋势。尽管如此,与早期文献中分居或离异女性的情况相比,这些分居或离异女性的状况似乎要好得多。英裔加拿大女性中抑郁症发病率较高以及使用治疗师的频率较高,被认为反映了她们支持性亲属网络较弱以及魁北克近期政治变化的影响。