Connolly C K
J R Coll Physicians Lond. 1983 Apr;17(2):115-20.
Five hundred and twenty-nine patients attended five different clinics supervised in three different ways in two adjacent, but socially different, health districts. Performance was apparently better in the clinics supervised by the consultant personally or by specialised junior staff. Non-atopic asthma appeared to be more frequent in clinics attended by patients with a social advantage, where it also appeared to be more easily controlled. This difference in control was less apparent in atopic asthma. These differences and deliberate selection probably account for the differences in performance between the clinics. Prescription policy appeared to be uniform throughout the clinics, though there was a tendency for drugs to be given at a lower level of pulmonary function in those clinics where performance was generally worse. Five per cent of all patients failed to achieve satisfactory treatment after a whole year's observation. This was not influenced by supervision or social group. Analysis of the pulmonary function of patients for whom drugs had been prescribed suggested that there was possible under-use of disodium cromoglycate as opposed to inhaled corticosteroids. The exercise proved a rapid and useful assessment of the performance of the clinics supervising asthma.
529名患者在两个相邻但社会情况不同的健康区,以三种不同方式监督的五家不同诊所就诊。由顾问亲自或由专业初级工作人员监督的诊所表现明显更好。非特应性哮喘在具有社会优势的患者就诊的诊所中似乎更常见,在这些诊所中它似乎也更容易控制。这种控制差异在特应性哮喘中不太明显。这些差异和刻意选择可能是诊所之间表现差异的原因。整个诊所的处方政策似乎是统一的,不过在表现普遍较差的诊所中,药物倾向于在肺功能较低水平时给予。在一整年的观察后,5%的患者未能获得满意的治疗。这不受监督或社会群体的影响。对已开处方患者的肺功能分析表明,与吸入性皮质类固醇相比,色甘酸钠可能使用不足。该实践证明是对哮喘监督诊所表现的快速且有用的评估。