Whiting M J, Bradley B M, Watts J M
Gut. 1983 Jan;24(1):11-5. doi: 10.1136/gut.24.1.11.
Of 406 consecutive patients with gall-bladder stones, 387 were treated by cholecystectomy and 19 were treated with chenodeoxycholic acid. The gall stones found in 356 of the 387 patients at operation were analysed chemically for cholesterol and calcium, physically for number, size, and mass, and radiologically before cholecystectomy for stone lucency. Gall stones rich in cholesterol (greater than 80% by weight) were present in 75% of patients, while pigment stones (less than 25% cholesterol) were found in 12% of patients. Out of the 406 gall-stone patients, 77 (19%) had functioning gall bladders which contained radiolucent stones 1.5 cm or less in diameter, thereby fulfilling the criteria which are used by most clinicians in selecting patients for dissolution therapy of cholesterol gall stones. The stones of 61 of these patients were available for chemical analysis and 52 (85%) were rich in cholesterol. Using the more stringent criterion for stone size of 1 cm or less in diameter, only 11% of patients had stones suitable for dissolution treatment. Taking into account other factors such as lack of compliance with treatment, obesity, and calcium salts in gall stones, it appears that no more than 10% of gall-stone patients presenting to a general hospital could be successfully treated with chenodeoxycholic acid.
在406例连续性胆囊结石患者中,387例行胆囊切除术,19例采用鹅去氧胆酸治疗。对387例手术患者中356例的胆结石进行了胆固醇和钙的化学分析、数量、大小和质量的物理分析,以及胆囊切除术前结石透亮度的放射学分析。75%的患者存在富含胆固醇的胆结石(重量超过80%),而12%的患者发现为色素结石(胆固醇含量低于25%)。在406例胆结石患者中,77例(19%)胆囊功能正常,其胆囊内含有直径1.5厘米或更小的透光结石,从而符合大多数临床医生选择胆固醇胆结石溶石治疗患者时所采用的标准。其中61例患者的结石可供化学分析,52例(85%)富含胆固醇。采用直径1厘米或更小的更严格结石大小标准时,只有11%的患者有适合溶石治疗的结石。考虑到其他因素,如治疗依从性差、肥胖和胆结石中的钙盐,看来综合医院就诊的胆结石患者中,不超过10%能用鹅去氧胆酸成功治疗。