Baker C L, Norwood L A, Hughston J C
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1983 Jun;65(5):614-8.
We reviewed the clinical records and operative notes of seventeen consecutive patients who were treated by surgical repair for acute posterolateral rotatory instability in order to determine the diagnostic features of the instability and the effectiveness of our surgical repair in thirteen patients who returned for objective and subjective evaluation after a mean follow-up of 53.3 months. Sixteen of the seventeen knees had a positive external-rotation recurvatum test; fifteen, a positive adduction-stress test at 30 degrees of knee flexion; and twelve, a positive posterolateral-drawer test. Associated rotatory instabilities were found in ten of the seventeen knees, with anterolateral rotatory instability being the most frequent. Two patients had associated peroneal-nerve palsy. One or more components of the arcuate ligament complex were injured in all seventeen knees. None of the thirteen patients who were followed required subsequent reconstruction for any chronic instability. Of these thirteen, the results in 85 per cent were rated good subjectively and in 77 per cent, good objectively. Eighty-five per cent of these patients had returned to athletic activity at their preinjury level; the remaining 15 per cent did not participate in sports activities. A positive posterolateral-drawer test or external rotation recurvatum test, or both, was diagnostic of posterolateral rotatory instability. The adduction stress test at 30 degrees of knee flexion was usually positive, but was not diagnostic. Accurate diagnosis and treatment of posterolateral rotatory instability in the acute stage can result in subjectively and objectively acceptable knee function.
我们回顾了17例因急性后外侧旋转不稳定接受手术修复治疗的连续患者的临床记录和手术记录,以确定该不稳定的诊断特征以及我们对13例患者进行手术修复的效果,这13例患者在平均随访53.3个月后接受了客观和主观评估。17个膝关节中有16个外旋后伸试验阳性;15个在膝关节屈曲30度时内收应力试验阳性;12个后外侧抽屉试验阳性。17个膝关节中有10个存在相关的旋转不稳定,其中前外侧旋转不稳定最为常见。2例患者伴有腓总神经麻痹。17个膝关节的弓状韧带复合体的一个或多个组成部分均有损伤。随访的13例患者中,无一例因任何慢性不稳定需要后续重建。在这13例患者中,85%的主观结果评定为良好,77%的客观结果评定为良好。这些患者中有85%已恢复到受伤前的运动水平;其余15%未参加体育活动。后外侧抽屉试验或外旋后伸试验阳性,或两者均阳性,可诊断为后外侧旋转不稳定。膝关节屈曲30度时的内收应力试验通常为阳性,但不能作为诊断依据。急性期后外侧旋转不稳定的准确诊断和治疗可使膝关节功能在主观和客观上都达到可接受的水平。