Waters D D, Bouchard A, Théroux P
J Am Coll Cardiol. 1983 Aug;2(2):195-9. doi: 10.1016/s0735-1097(83)80153-3.
To assess the prevalence of spontaneous remission in variant angina, 100 patients with this diagnosis who had undergone coronary arteriography in the hospital and a follow-up of at least 1 year were studied. Patients with coronary bypass surgery or myocardial infarction were excluded. Remission was diagnosed in 45 of the 100 patients who had been angina-free and had had no treatment for more than 3 months (mean 18.3). The other 55 patients were receiving medical treatment; 37 had been angina-free for at least 6 months (mean 22.5) and angina persisted in 18. The persistent angina group had a lower prevalence of organic coronary stenoses 70% or greater: 4 of 18 versus 22 of 45 and 22 of 37 for the other two groups (p less than 0.05), and a longer history of rest angina before admission. The remission group contained more patients (17 of 45 versus 4 of 55 [p less than 0.001]) whose attacks had been documented only by provocative testing. Rest angina recurred when calcium antagonist drugs were discontinued in 15 of 51 instances, within 1 month in 11 patients and later in 4 patients. Remission was eventually attained in 35 of the 38 patients in whom these drugs were stopped. These results indicate that remission is a frequent outcome of variant angina. This fact should be considered in the evaluation of the long-term results of treatment and in the planning of care for an individual patient.
为评估变异型心绞痛的自发缓解率,对100例在本院接受冠状动脉造影且随访至少1年的该诊断患者进行了研究。排除接受过冠状动脉搭桥手术或心肌梗死的患者。100例患者中,45例诊断为缓解,这些患者无心绞痛且未接受治疗超过3个月(平均18.3个月)。其余55例患者正在接受药物治疗;其中37例无心绞痛至少6个月(平均22.5个月),18例仍有心绞痛。持续性心绞痛组冠状动脉狭窄70%及以上的发生率较低:18例中有4例,而其他两组分别为45例中有22例和37例中有22例(p<0.05),且入院前静息性心绞痛病史更长。缓解组中更多患者(45例中有17例,而55例中有4例[p<0.001])的发作仅通过激发试验记录。51例患者中有15例停用钙拮抗剂药物后静息性心绞痛复发,11例在1个月内复发,4例在之后复发。停用这些药物的38例患者中,最终有35例实现缓解。这些结果表明,缓解是变异型心绞痛的常见转归。在评估治疗的长期结果以及为个体患者制定护理计划时应考虑这一事实。