Briggs R M, Holmes K K, Kiviat N, Barker E, Eschenbach D A, DeJong R
Am J Public Health. 1980 Nov;70(11):1212-4. doi: 10.2105/ajph.70.11.1212.
The results of routine cervical cytology screening at a Planned Parenthood Center (PPC) clinic were compared to those at a nearby sexually transmitted diseases (STD) clinic in Seattle. Cervical cytologic findings were consistent with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN), grades 1 (mild dysplasia), 2 (moderate dysplasia), or 3 (severe dysplasia to carcinoma in situ) in 502 (5.9 per cent) of 8,504 PPC patients and 87 (11.4 per cent) of 764 STD patients (p = .001). This rate for STD patients is five times that reported for the general population. Sixty-three PPC patients and 31 STD patients with screening smears consistent with CIN 1 or 2 underwent further prospective study by us, including repeated cytologic and colposcopic examinations. Thirty-seven (59 per cent) of 63 PPC patients and 26 (84 per cent) of 31 STD patients (p = .02) had at least on additional smear or colposcopy consistent with CIN and were advised to undergo cervical biopsy. Among those who underwent recommended biopsy, CIN was confirmed histologically in 15 (50 per cent) of 30 PPC patients and 11 (61 per cent) of 18 STD patients. Thus, the proportion of patients who had screening cytologic findings consistent with CIN, the proportion with persistent cytologic or colposcopic findings consistent with CIN on retesting, and the proportion of those biopsied who had histologically confirmed CIN, all were higher for STD than for PPC patients. There is a serious need for cytologic screening in STD clinics throughout the nation.
将计划生育中心(PPC)诊所的常规宫颈细胞学筛查结果与西雅图附近一家性传播疾病(STD)诊所的结果进行了比较。在8504名PPC患者中,有502名(5.9%)的宫颈细胞学检查结果与1级(轻度发育异常)、2级(中度发育异常)或3级(重度发育异常至原位癌)宫颈上皮内瘤变(CIN)相符;在764名STD患者中,有87名(11.4%)的结果与之相符(p = 0.001)。STD患者的这一比例是一般人群报告比例的五倍。63名PPC患者和31名STD患者的筛查涂片结果与CIN 1或2相符,我们对他们进行了进一步的前瞻性研究,包括重复细胞学和阴道镜检查。63名PPC患者中有37名(59%),31名STD患者中有26名(84%)(p = 0.02)至少有一次额外的涂片或阴道镜检查结果与CIN相符,并被建议进行宫颈活检。在接受推荐活检的患者中,30名PPC患者中有15名(50%),18名STD患者中有11名(61%)经组织学确诊为CIN。因此,STD患者中筛查细胞学检查结果与CIN相符的患者比例、复查时细胞学或阴道镜检查结果与CIN相符的持续患者比例以及活检后经组织学确诊为CIN的患者比例,均高于PPC患者。全美各地的STD诊所都迫切需要进行细胞学筛查。