Thomas P P, Crowell E B, Mathew M
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1982;76(5):620-3. doi: 10.1016/0035-9203(82)90224-3.
217 cases of tetanus admitted to Christian Medical College and Brown Memorial Hospital, Ludhiana, from June 1977 to April 1980 were studied. Three treatment regimes were used during this period. The addition of intrathecal horse antitetanus serum (ATS) (Group II) to the routine treatment (Group I) reduced the mortality from 63% to 53% but this was not statistically significant. Following a further addition of parenteral betamethasone to the regimen (Group III) the mortality decreased to 27% which was significantly lower than in Groups I and II. A similar trend in mortality was demonstrated when the severe cases were analysed separately. Groups I and III were comparable in terms of various prognostic factors and the nursing care received but Group II had a higher incidence of unfavourable prognostic factors, which may have obscured the benefit of intrathecal ATS. The combination of parenteral betamethasone and intrathecal ATS seems to be beneficial in the treatment of tetanus.
对1977年6月至1980年4月期间入住卢迪亚纳基督教医学院和布朗纪念医院的217例破伤风患者进行了研究。在此期间采用了三种治疗方案。在常规治疗(第一组)基础上加用鞘内注射马抗破伤风血清(ATS)(第二组),死亡率从63%降至53%,但差异无统计学意义。在该方案中进一步加用胃肠外倍他米松(第三组)后,死亡率降至27%,显著低于第一组和第二组。对重症病例单独分析时,死亡率也呈现类似趋势。第一组和第三组在各种预后因素及接受的护理方面具有可比性,但第二组不良预后因素的发生率较高,这可能掩盖了鞘内注射ATS的益处。胃肠外倍他米松和鞘内注射ATS联合应用似乎对破伤风治疗有益。