Heckman J D, Ingram A J, Loyd R D, Luck J V, Mayer P W
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1981 Nov-Dec(161):58-66.
Noninvasive, pulsed electromagnetic field treatment, when properly employed, was effective in securing healing of ununited fractures in 64.4% of 149 patients. The effectiveness of this modality can be ascertained after three months of intensive use in more than 85% of patients, thus enabling the clinician to decide to terminate treatment, continue electrostimulation, or abandon it in favor of another treatment modality. The success of treatment is dependent upon certain variables. Anatomic location of the nonunion is important. Higher healing rates were noted in the tibia than in the femur or humerus. In some conditions, combined electrostimulation and bone grafting was more effective than either measure alone. Young patients healed more rapidly than older patients. Electrostimulation is more effective when instituted within two years of the original fracture than when started at longer intervals after the injury. Infection, either quiescent or actively draining, does not seem to affect the overall results. Of greatest importance is patient adherence to the treatment protocol as outlined, with emphasis placed on adequate immobilization of the fracture and absolute nonweight-bearing during treatment. Considering these factors and in light of the very rare frequency of short-term side effects, the use of pulsed electromagnetic fields appears to be a reasonable choice of treatment in the management of ununited fractures.
无创脉冲电磁场治疗在正确应用时,对149例患者中的64.4%的骨不连愈合有效。在85%以上的患者中,经过三个月的强化使用后,这种治疗方式的有效性可以确定,从而使临床医生能够决定终止治疗、继续电刺激治疗或放弃该治疗而选择另一种治疗方式。治疗的成功取决于某些变量。骨不连的解剖位置很重要。胫骨的愈合率高于股骨或肱骨。在某些情况下,联合电刺激和植骨比单独任何一种措施都更有效。年轻患者比老年患者愈合得更快。在原始骨折后两年内开始电刺激比在损伤后更长时间开始更有效。静止或有活动性引流的感染似乎不影响总体结果。最重要的是患者遵守所概述的治疗方案,重点是骨折的充分固定和治疗期间绝对不负重。考虑到这些因素,并且鉴于短期副作用的发生率极低,脉冲电磁场的使用似乎是治疗骨不连的合理选择。