Marks I M, Stern R S, Mawson D, Cobb J, McDonald R
Br J Psychiatry. 1980 Jan;136:1-25. doi: 10.1192/bjp.136.1.1.
Forty chronic obsessive-compulsive ritualizers were randomly assigned to treatment with oral clomipramine or placebo for 8 months. During weeks 4 to 7 these two groups were each randomly split into treatment by relaxation or by exposure in vivo, and during weeks 7 to 10 all patients had exposure in vivo. Double blind assessments were made at weeks 4, 7, 10, 18, 36, 62 and 114. Results are reported to one year. Clomipramine produced significant improvement in rituals, mood and social adjustment, but only in those patients who initially had depressed mood. The clomipramine effect was maximum from weeks 10 to 18 and diminished thereafter. On stopping clomipramine patients often relapsed and improved again on restarting the drug. Relaxation produced little change. Exposure produced significant lasting improvement in rituals, but less change in mood; improvement generalized to social adjustment at follow-up. Clomipramine plus exposure had a slight additive but not interactional effect. Clomipramine enhanced compliance both with exposure and with relaxation. Clomipramine is useful for compulsive ritualizers with depressed mood, but may need continuation for over a year and combination with exposure in vivo. Exposure in vivo remains the treatment of choice for rituals without depressed mood.
40名慢性强迫仪式行为患者被随机分配接受口服氯米帕明或安慰剂治疗,为期8个月。在第4至7周,这两组患者又各自被随机分为接受放松治疗组或现场暴露治疗组,在第7至10周,所有患者都接受现场暴露治疗。在第4、7、10、18、36、62和114周进行双盲评估。结果报告至一年。氯米帕明使仪式行为、情绪和社会适应能力有显著改善,但仅在那些最初有抑郁情绪的患者中有效。氯米帕明的效果在第10至18周达到最大,此后逐渐减弱。停用氯米帕明后患者常复发,重新用药后又有改善。放松治疗几乎没有变化。现场暴露治疗使仪式行为有显著的持续改善,但情绪变化较小;随访时改善扩展到社会适应能力。氯米帕明加现场暴露治疗有轻微的相加作用,但无交互作用。氯米帕明增强了患者对现场暴露治疗和放松治疗的依从性。氯米帕明对有抑郁情绪的强迫仪式行为患者有用,但可能需要持续用药一年以上并结合现场暴露治疗。对于没有抑郁情绪的仪式行为,现场暴露治疗仍是首选治疗方法。