Brown P, Salmon P R, Burwood R J, Knox A J, Clendinnen B G, Read A E
Scand J Gastroenterol. 1978;13(5):557-60. doi: 10.3109/00365527809181764.
A prospective study of the endoscopic, radiological, and surgical features of chronic duodenal ulceration has been performed. Double contrast barium meal and upper gastrointestinal endoscopy were both performed within five days of elective surgery for chronic duodenal ulceration on 50 patients. The surgical diagnosis correlated with endoscopy in 88% and radiology in 82%, but if both techniques were employed, an accurate pre-operative diagnosis was achieved in 96% of cases. There was poorer correlation in determining the position of the ulcer within the bulb, with only 41% correlation between all three parameters and complete disagreement in 24%. Surgery correlated with endoscopy in 71% but with radiology in only 41%. The correlation between endoscopy and surgery in the diagnosis of duodenitis was only 42%, suggesting that this should be a histological diagnosis. This study suggests that endoscopy is slightly more precise than radiology in the diagnosis of chronic duodenal ulceration, but with a combination of the two techniques almost 100% accuracy can be achieved.
对慢性十二指肠溃疡的内镜、放射学及手术特征进行了一项前瞻性研究。对50例因慢性十二指肠溃疡接受择期手术的患者,在手术前五天内均进行了双重对比钡餐检查和上消化道内镜检查。手术诊断与内镜诊断的符合率为88%,与放射学诊断的符合率为82%,但如果同时采用这两种技术,则96%的病例可实现准确的术前诊断。在确定溃疡位于十二指肠球部的位置方面,相关性较差,所有三个参数之间的相关性仅为41%,24%完全不一致。手术与内镜诊断的符合率为71%,但与放射学诊断的符合率仅为41%。内镜检查与手术在十二指肠炎症诊断中的相关性仅为42%,这表明十二指肠炎症应通过组织学诊断。这项研究表明,在内镜诊断慢性十二指肠溃疡方面,内镜比放射学稍精确,但两种技术联合使用可实现近100%的准确率。