Brühlmann T, Brühlmann-Keller H, Thalmann R, Sonnenberg A, Schmid P, Blum A L
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1978 Sep 16;108(37):1413-20.
Of the 153 heads of surgical departments in Switzerland, 152 joined in an inquiry into diagnostic procedures, surgical indications, and types of procedure in the treatment of axial hiatal hernia and reflux disease. Fundoplication is by far the most frequent procedure. Of the modifications performed in complicated reflux disease, 34% are controversial. Surgery for hiatal hernia and reflux disease is performed 3 times less frequently in the German part of Switzerland than in the other parts. German-speaking surgeons ascribe to themselves a greater willingness to perform preoperative diagnostic procedures--endoscopy, radiological and non-radiological tests of esophageal function--than the surgeons of the other parts of Switzerland. However, the German-speaking surgeons are more reluctant than the other surgeons to perform surgery in patients with esophagitis. The German-speaking surgeons are even more reluctant to perform surgery on the basis of subjective symptoms. Axial hiatal hernia is considered a relative indication for surgery by half of Swiss surgeons. Only a few surgeons consider this condition an absolute indication for surgery.
在瑞士的153名外科科室主任中,152人参与了一项关于治疗食管裂孔疝和反流性疾病的诊断程序、手术指征及手术类型的调查。胃底折叠术是目前最常用的手术。在复杂反流性疾病所进行的手术改良中,34%存在争议。瑞士德语区进行食管裂孔疝和反流性疾病手术的频率比其他地区少三倍。说德语的外科医生认为自己比瑞士其他地区的外科医生更愿意进行术前诊断程序——内镜检查、食管功能的放射学和非放射学检查。然而,说德语的外科医生比其他外科医生更不愿意对食管炎患者进行手术。说德语的外科医生甚至更不愿意基于主观症状进行手术。一半的瑞士外科医生认为食管裂孔疝是手术的相对指征。只有少数外科医生认为这种情况是手术的绝对指征。