Goldman L, Weinberg M, Weisberg M, Olshen R, Cook E F, Sargent R K, Lamas G A, Dennis C, Wilson C, Deckelbaum L, Fineberg H, Stiratelli R
N Engl J Med. 1982 Sep 2;307(10):588-96. doi: 10.1056/NEJM198209023071004.
To determine whether data available to physicians in the emergency room can accurately identify which patients with acute chest pain are having myocardial infarctions, we analyzed 482 patients at one hospital. Using recursive partitioning analysis, we constructed a decision protocol in the format of a simple flow chart to identify infarction on the basis of nine clinical factors. In prospective testing on 468 other patients at a second hospital, the protocol performed as well as the physicians. Moreover, an integration of the protocol with the physicians' judgments resulted in a classification system that preserved sensitivity for detecting infarctions, significantly improved the specificity (from 67 per cent to 77 per cent, P less than 0.01) and positive predictive value (from 34 per cent to 42 per cent, P = 0.016) of admission to an intensive-care area. The protocol identified a subgroup of 107 patients among whom only 5 per cent had infarctions and for whom admission to non-intensive-care areas might be appropriate. This decision protocol warrants further wide-scale prospective testing but is not ready for routine clinical use.
为了确定急诊室医生可获取的数据能否准确识别哪些急性胸痛患者患有心肌梗死,我们对一家医院的482名患者进行了分析。通过递归划分分析,我们构建了一个以简单流程图形式呈现的决策方案,以便根据九个临床因素来识别梗死情况。在对另一家医院的468名其他患者进行的前瞻性测试中,该方案的表现与医生相当。此外,将该方案与医生的判断相结合,形成了一个分类系统,该系统在检测梗死方面保持了敏感性,显著提高了重症监护病房收治的特异性(从67%提高到77%,P<0.01)和阳性预测值(从34%提高到42%,P = 0.016)。该方案识别出了一个107名患者的亚组,其中只有5%患有梗死,这些患者可能适合入住非重症监护病房。这个决策方案值得进一步进行大规模前瞻性测试,但尚未准备好用于常规临床应用。