Monahan J, Ruggiero M, Friedlander H D
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1982 Nov;39(11):1267-71. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1982.04290110029005.
Professional opposition to making "dangerousness" the primary criterion for involuntary civil commitment has galvanized in support of the proposed "new medical model." The Stone-Roth criteria for commitment were applied to patients being committed under California's version of the dangerousness standard. Results showed that 86% of the patients committed under the California statute were viewed by the examining psychiatrists as committable under the Stone-Roth procedures as well.
专业人士反对将“危险性”作为非自愿民事收容的首要标准,这一反对意见凝聚起来支持了提议的“新医学模式”。将斯通 - 罗斯收容标准应用于根据加利福尼亚州危险性标准被收容的患者。结果显示,在加利福尼亚州法规下被收容的患者中,86% 的患者经检查的精神科医生判定也可依据斯通 - 罗斯程序被收容。