Dunn D M, O'Riordan S M
Dev Med Child Neurol. 1981 Apr;23(2):202-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.1981.tb02442.x.
A cohort of children presenting with clicking hips was studied in two districts. In one district any child with a clicking hip was treated as though the hip was dislocated, i.e. by splintage in abduction, but in the other district no treatment was offered. None of the 'treated' group later presented with a dislocated hip, whereas four children were found with dislocated hips among the 'untreated' group. A further four children who were not treated because their hips appeared to be normal on the second examination later presented with dislocated hips. It is suggested that the accuracy of diagnosis in all units might be improved if the examination of the newborn was carried out by a limited number of doctors to whom greater experience would accrue. Further improvements would be made if any hip which was found to click on examination was treated as an unstable hip and splinted in abduction.
在两个地区对一组出现髋关节弹响的儿童进行了研究。在一个地区,任何有髋关节弹响的儿童都被当作髋关节脱位来治疗,即采用外展夹板固定,但在另一个地区则不进行治疗。“接受治疗”组中后来没有出现髋关节脱位的情况,而在“未治疗”组中发现有4名儿童出现了髋关节脱位。另外4名儿童因为在第二次检查时髋关节看起来正常而未接受治疗,后来也出现了髋关节脱位。有人认为,如果由数量有限且经验更丰富的医生对新生儿进行检查,所有医疗机构的诊断准确性可能会提高。如果将检查时发现有弹响的任何髋关节都当作不稳定髋关节并采用外展夹板固定,将会有进一步的改善。