Kay L, Stainsby D, Buzzard B, Fearns M, Hamilton P J, Owen P, Jones P
Br J Haematol. 1981 Sep;49(1):53-60. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2141.1981.tb07196.x.
Between August 1973 and May 1979, 18 patients suffering from severe haemophilia A underwent synovectomy for recurrent haemarthroses, resistant to medical management. A total of 23 joints (11 knees and 12 elbows) were subjected to operation, five patients undergoing two synovectomies on different joints. Post-operative follow-up period ranged from 12 to 58 months for elbow synovectomy and from 29 to 76 months for knee synovectomy. All patients experienced fewer haemarthroses, the average number of bleeding episodes per joint over a 12 month period being reduced from 19 to 3 for knee joints, and from 24 to 3 for elbow joints. This improvement was apparent in the immediate post-operative year and maintained thereafter. Over the same follow-up period nine of the 11 knee joints were found to have lost an average 42 degrees mobility. Following elbow synovectomy five out of 12 patients lost an average of 28 degrees mobility; six patients gained an average 11 degrees mobility. The post-operative complication rate was high for knee synovectomy, 54% suffering haemorrhage despite haemostatic factor VIII levels. For elbow synovectomy the rate was much lower, 75% of operations being uncomplicated. The average in-patient time for knee operation was 75 d, and for the elbow 19 d. We conclude that synovectomy of the knee joint is to be avoided when other means of reducing bleeding episodes are available, whereas elbow synovectomy retains a useful role in the treatment of recurrent haemarthroses which do not respond to clotting factor prophylaxis.
1973年8月至1979年5月期间,18例重度甲型血友病患者因反复关节积血且药物治疗无效而接受了滑膜切除术。总共23个关节(11个膝关节和12个肘关节)接受了手术,5例患者在不同关节接受了两次滑膜切除术。肘关节滑膜切除术后的随访期为12至58个月,膝关节滑膜切除术后的随访期为29至76个月。所有患者的关节积血次数均减少,膝关节每个关节在12个月期间的平均出血次数从19次降至3次,肘关节从24次降至3次。这种改善在术后即刻就很明显,并在此后得以维持。在相同的随访期内,11个膝关节中有9个平均丧失了42度的活动度。肘关节滑膜切除术后,12例患者中有5例平均丧失了28度的活动度;6例患者平均增加了11度的活动度。膝关节滑膜切除术的术后并发症发生率较高,尽管有止血因子VIII水平,但仍有54%的患者发生出血。肘关节滑膜切除术的发生率则低得多,75%的手术无并发症。膝关节手术的平均住院时间为75天,肘关节手术为19天。我们得出结论,当有其他减少出血发作的方法时,应避免进行膝关节滑膜切除术,而肘关节滑膜切除术在治疗对凝血因子预防无反应的反复关节积血方面仍具有有用的作用。