Rodriquez Merchan E C, Galindo E, Ladreda J M, Pardo J A
Haemophilia Unit, La Paz, Orthopaedic and Traumatology Hospital, Madrid, Spain.
Int Orthop. 1994 Feb;18(1):38-41. doi: 10.1007/BF00180177.
Twenty seven patients with haemophilia who had repeated haemarthroses affecting the knee joint, despite appropriate substitution therapy, were treated by surgical synovectomy. Open operations were carried out on 18 and 9 had an arthroscopic procedure. The average age at the time of synovectomy was 13 years for both the open and arthroscopic groups. The open group was followed up for an average of 15.2 years and the closed for 5.4 years. Operation took 70 minutes on average in the arthroscopic group and 50 minutes in the open. Patients who had an arthroscopy were in hospital for an average of 5 days and those with an open operation for 10. Synovectomy by both methods significantly reduced bleeding episodes. The results were assessed according to the classification recommended by the Orthopaedic Advisory Committee of the World Federation of Haemophilia. In the open group 2 patients had a good result, 10 were fair and 6 poor; in the arthroscopic group 3 had a good result, 5 were fair and 1 poor. Both operations appeared to slow, but did not halt, the radiographic deterioration of the joints.
27例血友病患者,尽管接受了适当的替代治疗,但膝关节仍反复发生关节积血,均接受了手术滑膜切除术治疗。其中18例行开放手术,9例行关节镜手术。开放手术组和关节镜手术组滑膜切除时的平均年龄均为13岁。开放手术组平均随访15.2年,关节镜手术组平均随访5.4年。关节镜手术组手术平均耗时70分钟,开放手术组平均耗时50分钟。接受关节镜手术的患者平均住院5天,接受开放手术的患者平均住院10天。两种方法的滑膜切除术均显著减少了出血发作次数。结果根据世界血友病联盟骨科咨询委员会推荐的分类进行评估。开放手术组中,2例效果良好,10例一般,6例较差;关节镜手术组中,3例效果良好,5例一般,1例较差。两种手术似乎都减缓了关节的影像学退变,但并未阻止其发展。