Lindsay W R
Br J Soc Clin Psychol. 1980 Feb;19(1):85-98. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8260.1980.tb00933.x.
This report provides an account of a conversation training programme for psychiatric in-patients, developed on the basis of previous work in the area and on analyses of normal conversations carried out by the author. A further aim was to generalize these increases in social behaviour to patients' general ward settings. Generalization procedures include tasks for patients to do between training sessions and a reduction in the number of stimulus differences between treatment and generalization settings. Two control groups were employed to assess the effectiveness of this treatment as compared to (1) an existing behavioural approach to the problem of withdrawn patients and (2) a group who received similar increases in staff attention, tangible reinforcement, and who also had their own attention focused on social behaviour. This latter control group then went on to receive the training given to the experimental group. Patients were assessed before treatment, after treatment and at 8-week follow-up. Measures were taken on frequency of conversation during treatment, frequency of conversation on the ward, quality of various social behaviours during videotaped interviews and quality of social behaviours during audiotaped conversations. The results indicate the following: (1) both behavioural treatments increased patients' utterances during treatment sessions; (2) the experimental treatment was superior in generalizing this increased frequency, although these increases reduced at follow-up; (3) the experimental group show some superiority when assessed on videotape, and gains made in the quality of interaction do not reverse as markedly as in frequency; (4) on the audiotaped conversations, the experimental group improved their social ability considerably and these improvements were still evident at follow-up. The behavioural treatment control showed some improvements on generalized measures but not as much or as consistently as the experimental group. The attention control group went on to replicate the experimental group treatments and results.
本报告介绍了一项针对精神科住院患者的对话训练计划,该计划是在该领域以往工作以及作者对正常对话分析的基础上制定的。另一个目标是将这些社交行为的增加推广到患者的普通病房环境中。推广程序包括患者在训练课程之间要完成的任务,以及减少治疗环境和推广环境之间的刺激差异数量。采用了两个对照组来评估这种治疗方法的有效性,与(1)一种现有的针对退缩患者问题的行为方法,以及(2)一组在工作人员关注、实际强化方面有类似增加,且自身注意力也集中在社交行为上的患者进行比较。后一个对照组随后接受了给予实验组的训练。在治疗前、治疗后以及8周随访时对患者进行评估。在治疗期间对对话频率、病房内对话频率、录像访谈期间各种社交行为的质量以及录音对话期间社交行为的质量进行了测量。结果表明:(1)两种行为治疗方法在治疗期间都增加了患者的话语量;(2)实验性治疗在推广这种增加的频率方面更具优势,尽管这些增加在随访时有所减少;(3)在录像评估时,实验组显示出一些优势,互动质量方面的提高不像频率方面那样明显逆转;(4)在录音对话中,实验组的社交能力有了相当大的提高,并且这些提高在随访时仍然明显。行为治疗对照组在推广测量方面有一些改善,但不如实验组那么多或那么一致。注意力对照组随后重复了实验组的治疗和结果。