Rodriguez-Budelli M M, Kark R A, Blass J P, Spence M A
Adv Neurol. 1978;21:195-202.
Physostigmine improved videotape scores of ataxia in patients with various inherited ataxias. This improvement occurred in 12 out of 12 patients when the drug was given as a single dose and in nine of 11 patients when the drug and placebo were given in a long-term, double-blind randomized trial. Patients report various mild to moderate clinical benefits after the sustained use of physostigmine for 6 to 36 months. Videotape scores showed an average of 30% numerical improvement in seven patients after 6 months' sustained treatment. The acute responses are not blocked by methylscopolamine, methylscopolamine did not make ataxia more severe, nor have any patients had fasciculations or changes in strength while on physostigmine. We therefore presume that a central cholinergic mechanism plays some role in the pathophysiology of the inherited ataxias. We do not have direct data on the site or nature of this mechanism. Further studies with other cholinergic agents are now required to investigate the effects and potential clinical efficacy of this class of compounds more completely than has been done up to now.
毒扁豆碱改善了各种遗传性共济失调患者的录像带共济失调评分。单次给药时,12例患者中有12例出现改善;在一项长期、双盲随机试验中,给予药物和安慰剂时,11例患者中有9例出现改善。患者在持续使用毒扁豆碱6至36个月后报告了各种轻度至中度的临床益处。录像带评分显示,7例患者在持续治疗6个月后平均数值改善30%。急性反应不受甲基东莨菪碱的阻断,甲基东莨菪碱不会使共济失调加重,在使用毒扁豆碱期间也没有患者出现肌束震颤或肌力变化。因此,我们推测中枢胆碱能机制在遗传性共济失调的病理生理学中起一定作用。我们没有关于该机制的部位或性质的直接数据。现在需要用其他胆碱能药物进行进一步研究,以比迄今为止更全面地研究这类化合物的作用和潜在临床疗效。