Fraher J P
J Anat. 1980 Jan;130(Pt 1):139-51.
Various methods of measuring axonal circumference and cross sectional area were examined. In measuring circumference, the Reichert MOP semi-automatic image analysis system varied more than a map meter. Several methods of area measurement were compared. Though all were relatively accurate in the long run, variability of individual measurements differed from one method to another, being greatest with a rolling disc planimeter and least with the method of counting millimetre squares within the profile to be measured. The map meter and the MOP were compared in measuring the circumferences of a large sample of axons: the latter method was significantly the more variable. Also, the MOP gave values significantly greater than the map meter. Comparison was also made of area measurements on the same large sample of axons, using various methods. Apart from the MOP and the rolling disc planimeter, each method gave area estimates significantly different from all others. The differences were in some cases as great as 4%. There was no significant correlation between the error involved and the size of the axon in measuring axonal circumference or area. Of all the methods studied, the MOP was the most efficient in measuring both circumference and area in terms of time taken and versatility. So long as a particular study is confined to comparing sets of measurements made by the same method, the systematic errors reported above are relatively unimportant. However, in comparing sets of measurements made with different methods, systematic errors may be important and should be borne in mind.
研究了多种测量轴突周长和横截面积的方法。在测量周长时,Reichert MOP半自动图像分析系统的变化比地图测量仪更大。比较了几种面积测量方法。虽然从长远来看,所有方法都相对准确,但不同方法的单次测量变异性各不相同,其中用滚动圆盘式面积仪测量时变异性最大,而用在待测轮廓内计数毫米方格的方法时变异性最小。在测量大量轴突的周长时,对地图测量仪和MOP进行了比较:后一种方法的变异性明显更大。此外,MOP得出的值明显大于地图测量仪。还使用各种方法对同一大量轴突样本的面积测量进行了比较。除了MOP和滚动圆盘式面积仪外,每种方法得出的面积估计值与其他所有方法都有显著差异。在某些情况下,差异高达4%。在测量轴突周长或面积时,所涉及的误差与轴突大小之间没有显著相关性。在所研究的所有方法中,就测量时间和通用性而言,MOP在测量周长和面积方面效率最高。只要特定研究仅限于比较用相同方法进行的几组测量,上述系统误差相对不重要。然而,在比较用不同方法进行的几组测量时,系统误差可能很重要,应予以考虑。