Collea J V, Chein C, Quilligan E J
Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1980 May 15;137(2):235-44. doi: 10.1016/0002-9378(80)90780-2.
A prospective study of 208 women in labor at term with singleton fetuses in a frank breech presentation was carried out. One hundred fifteen patients were randomized to a vaginal delivery group and 93 to an elective cesarean section group. Of the 93 women scheduled for cesarean section, 88 were delivered according to protocol. Five women progressed rapidly in labor and were delivered vaginally without complications. Of the 115 women scheduled for vaginal delivery, x-ray pelvimetry was obtained on 112. Three women were delivered vaginally without incident before x-ray pelvimetry could be obtained. One of these women was delivered of an infant who died shortly after birth of lethal congenital anomalies. Of the 112 women with x-ray pelvimetry, 52 had one or more inadequate pelvic measurements and were scheduled for indicated cesarean section. Three women, however, were delivered vaginally without incident before operation could be performed. Of the remaining 60 patients in this group, 49 were delivered vaginally without a perinatal death. Eleven women required cesarean section for difficulties during labor. There were no maternal deaths, but 73 (49.3%) of the 148 women who were delivered by cesarean section in this study experienced postpartum morbidity. Only four (6.7%) of the 60 women delivered vaginally had postpartum complications. Based on the data, it seems resonable to allow vaginal delivery in carefully selected cases of term frank breech presentation.
对208名单胎足月臀先露分娩的女性进行了一项前瞻性研究。115名患者被随机分配到阴道分娩组,93名被分配到择期剖宫产组。在计划剖宫产的93名女性中,88名按方案进行了剖宫产。5名女性产程进展迅速,经阴道分娩且无并发症。在计划阴道分娩的115名女性中,112名进行了X线骨盆测量。3名女性在获得X线骨盆测量结果之前就顺利经阴道分娩。其中一名女性分娩的婴儿出生后不久因致命的先天性异常死亡。在进行X线骨盆测量的112名女性中,52名有一项或多项骨盆测量值不充分,计划行择期剖宫产。然而,3名女性在手术前就顺利经阴道分娩。在该组其余60名患者中,49名经阴道分娩且无围产期死亡。11名女性因分娩困难需要剖宫产。无孕产妇死亡,但本研究中148名剖宫产分娩的女性中有73名(49.3%)出现产后并发症。60名经阴道分娩的女性中只有4名(6.7%)有产后并发症。根据这些数据,在精心挑选的足月臀先露病例中允许阴道分娩似乎是合理的。