Bigelow G, Stitzer M, Lawrence C, Krasnegor N, D'Lugoff B, Hawthorne J
Int J Addict. 1980 Apr;15(3):427-37. doi: 10.3109/10826088009040028.
Methadone maintenance patients were assigned among four treatment cells involving contingency management, emotionally-based behavior therapy, a combination of these, or a control condition receiving counseling but no behavioral treatment. With 60 patients who remained in treatment at least 6 months, treatment outcomes were compared using objective measures: hours employed, urinalysis results, and counseling participation. No significant differences were found between modalities. Case studies suggested that under appropriate conditions, contingency management might reduce illicit drug use. It is suggested that focused experimental studies may be more productive than broad clinical outcome evaluations.
美沙酮维持治疗患者被分配到四个治疗组中,分别涉及应急管理、基于情绪的行为疗法、两者结合,或接受咨询但无行为治疗的对照条件。对60名至少接受6个月治疗的患者,使用客观指标比较治疗结果:工作时长、尿液分析结果和咨询参与情况。各治疗方式之间未发现显著差异。案例研究表明,在适当条件下,应急管理可能会减少非法药物使用。建议有针对性的实验研究可能比广泛的临床结果评估更有成效。