Cooper M R, Pajak T F, Nissen N I, Stutzman L, Brunner K, Cuttner J, Falkson G, Grunwald H, Bank A, Leone L, Seligman B R, Silver R T, Weiss R B, Haurani F, Blom J, Spurr C L, Glidewell O J, Gottlieb A J, Holland J F
Cancer. 1980 Aug 15;46(4):654-62. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(19800815)46:4<654::aid-cncr2820460405>3.0.co;2-a.
Five hundred and sixty-six patients with either Stage III or IV Hodgkin's disease were prospectively randomized to test whether CCNU and/or vinblastine are more effective than mechlorethamine and/or vincristine with procarbazine and prednisone. The combination of CCNU, vinblastine, procarbazine, and prednisone (CVPP) was shown to be a highly effective program with a complete response frequency of 69%. The use of CCNU as part of the induction program was also shown to be the most significant determinant of prolonged remissions (P = .025). Reduced vomiting and neurotoxicity, as well as the oral administration, were the chief advantages of the CVPP as compared with MOPP. These factors resulted in improved patient and physician compliance. The MVPP regimen was also shown to be a highly effective regimen with a complete response frequency of 73% in patients without prior exposure to chemotherapy. However, the induction regimens containing vinblastine were associated with a significantly higher frequency of fatal hematopoietic toxicities than the induction regimens containing vincristine (P = .05). This higher frequency was almost exclusively seen in the elderly or in patients previously treated with both chemotherapy and radiotherapy. At this time, the remission durations maintained by vinblastine with periodic reinforcement are longer when compared with vinblastine maintenance alone (P = .06), but there is no corresponding increase in survival.
566例Ⅲ期或Ⅳ期霍奇金病患者被前瞻性随机分组,以测试洛莫司汀和/或长春花碱是否比氮芥和/或长春新碱联合丙卡巴肼及泼尼松更有效。洛莫司汀、长春花碱、丙卡巴肼和泼尼松(CVPP)联合方案显示为一种高效方案,完全缓解率达69%。洛莫司汀作为诱导方案的一部分使用也被证明是缓解期延长的最显著决定因素(P = 0.025)。与MOPP相比,CVPP的主要优势在于呕吐和神经毒性减轻以及口服给药。这些因素使患者和医生的依从性得到改善。MVPP方案在未接受过化疗的患者中也显示为一种高效方案,完全缓解率达73%。然而,含长春花碱的诱导方案与含长春新碱的诱导方案相比,致命性血液学毒性的发生率显著更高(P = 0.05)。这种更高的发生率几乎仅见于老年人或既往接受过化疗和放疗的患者。此时,与单独使用长春花碱维持治疗相比,定期强化使用长春花碱维持的缓解期更长(P = 0.06),但生存率并无相应提高。