Spaeth G, Gottwald T, Hirner A
Department of Surgery, University of Bonn, Germany.
Eur J Surg. 1995 Jul;161(7):513-8.
To assess the effect of six different enteral diets on the gut barrier.
Laboratory study.
University hospital, Germany.
70 Specific pathogen free female Crl:CDR BR rats.
For 7 days, 6 groups of rats were fed orally with standard chow (n = 15); total parenteral nutrition solution (oral TPN, n = 15); elemental diet (ED, n = 10); nutrient-defined diet (NDD, n = 10); or the NDD supplemented with uracil (NDD+uracil, n = 10), or fibre (NDD+fibre, n = 10).
Bacterial translocation to mesenteric lymph nodes, numbers of Gram negative enterobacteria and total aerobic bacteria in the caecum, and intestinal concentrations of secretory IgA.
The incidence of bacterial translocation was significantly increased in the groups given oral TPN, ED, NDD, and NDD+uracil compared with the group given chow. Only NDD+fibre resulted in a similar degree of translocation to that in the chow group. All groups in which there was increased translocation had a highly significant overgrowth of aerobic bacteria in the caecum, mainly by Gram negative enteric organisms. The secretory IgA concentration was reduced in the group that had been given oral TPN, and that in the ED and NDD+uracil groups was similar to that in the chow group. NDD and NDD+fibre were associated with higher intestinal concentrations of secretory IgA than chow.
Fibre-free enteral diets do not protect the gut antimicrobial barrier whatever else is in them. The superiority of early enteral as opposed to parenteral nutrition after injury may, therefore, not be the result of a specific protective effect on the gut barrier. The supplementation of commercial enteral diets with bulk fibre should be tested in clinical trials.
评估六种不同肠内饮食对肠道屏障的影响。
实验室研究。
德国大学医院。
70只无特定病原体的雌性Crl:CDR BR大鼠。
6组大鼠连续7天经口给予标准饲料(n = 15);全胃肠外营养溶液(经口TPN,n = 15);要素饮食(ED,n = 10);营养素定义饮食(NDD,n = 10);或补充尿嘧啶的NDD(NDD + 尿嘧啶,n = 10),或补充纤维的NDD(NDD + 纤维,n = 10)。
细菌易位至肠系膜淋巴结的情况、盲肠中革兰氏阴性肠杆菌和需氧菌总数,以及肠道分泌型IgA浓度。
与给予标准饲料的组相比,经口给予TPN、ED、NDD和NDD + 尿嘧啶的组中细菌易位发生率显著增加。只有NDD + 纤维导致的易位程度与标准饲料组相似。所有易位增加的组盲肠中需氧菌均过度生长,主要是革兰氏阴性肠道菌。经口给予TPN的组中分泌型IgA浓度降低,ED和NDD + 尿嘧啶组中的浓度与标准饲料组相似。NDD和NDD + 纤维组肠道分泌型IgA浓度高于标准饲料组。
不含纤维的肠内饮食无论含有其他何种成分,均不能保护肠道抗菌屏障。因此,损伤后早期肠内营养相对于肠外营养的优势,可能并非对肠道屏障的特异性保护作用所致。应在临床试验中测试在商业肠内饮食中添加大量纤维的效果。