Langmore S E
Audiology & Speech Pathology Service (126), VA Medical Center, Ann Arbor, MI 48105, USA.
Dysphagia. 1995 Fall;10(4):259-62. doi: 10.1007/BF00431419.
In this critique of research in behavioral treatment of dysphagia, three types of investigations are briefly reviewed: general management guides, specific behavioral treatments applied to single patients or a few patients, and dysphagia programs applied to large numbers of patients. Efficacy of treatment has been demonstrated in some of the single-case or small-group studies where specific techniques have been utilized. Unfortunately, efficacy has not been demonstrated in any of the studies where large groups of patients have been enrolled in dysphagia programs. Some of the critical factors that have been lacking in many of these studies are discussed and the need to include functional outcome measures in efficacy studies is emphasized.
在这篇对吞咽困难行为治疗研究的评论中,简要回顾了三种类型的调查:一般管理指南、应用于单个患者或少数患者的特定行为治疗,以及应用于大量患者的吞咽困难治疗方案。在一些使用特定技术的单病例或小组研究中已证明了治疗的有效性。不幸的是,在任何将大量患者纳入吞咽困难治疗方案的研究中,均未证明其有效性。讨论了许多此类研究中缺乏的一些关键因素,并强调在疗效研究中纳入功能结局指标的必要性。