Kuntz J B, Carrier J K, Hollis J H
Monogr Am Assoc Ment Defic. 1978(3):145-91.
This study investigated the development of nonvocal teaching of reading and writing in severely retarded children. Fourteen subjects were selected who demonstrated limited communication skills, and were randomly placed into two groups. Group A received training procedures utilizing abstract plastic symbols which were arbitrarily assigned to represent specific words. The training program was divided into three phases. Phase I consisted of training left to right sequencing of four color--coded forms; Phase II consisted of training of matching symbols to stimulus pictures; and Phase III consisted of training of fading from symbols to printed words. The subjects completing this training program demonstrated the ability to learn selected reading and writing skills, i.e., they learned to sequence an article, subject noun, auxiliary verb, and verb. They also demonstrated functional semantic comprehension of five nouns and five verbs. Thirteen subjects finished the communication training program in less than four months with a mean training of 7 hours and 55 minutes. This is approximately 2 hours of training a month per subject to learn these skills. The data showed that Group B (rebuses) required fewer trials than Group A (abstract symbols) to meet criterion for Phase II, matching symbols to stimulus pictures. This suggests that Group B subjects may have had a meaningful association for the rebus signs which generalized to stimulus pictures. Group A (abstract symbols) required fewer trials than Group B (rebuse) to meet criterion for Phase 111, matching printed words to stimulus pictures. This indicates that perhaps Group A's training with abstract symbols positively affected learning to read printed words. The success of the visual nonvocal treatment program with the severely retarded is encouraging. Indeed, this is a different and viable approach in teaching communication skills (reading and writing) to the retarded.
本研究调查了重度智力迟钝儿童读写非语言教学的发展情况。选取了14名沟通能力有限的受试者,并将他们随机分为两组。A组接受利用抽象塑料符号的训练程序,这些符号被任意指定用来代表特定的单词。训练计划分为三个阶段。第一阶段包括训练对四种颜色编码形式从左到右排序;第二阶段包括训练将符号与刺激图片匹配;第三阶段包括训练从符号逐渐过渡到印刷单词。完成该训练计划的受试者展示了学习特定读写技能的能力,即他们学会了对一篇文章、主语名词、助动词和动词进行排序。他们还展示了对五个名词和五个动词的功能性语义理解。13名受试者在不到四个月的时间内完成了沟通训练计划,平均训练时长为7小时55分钟。这大约是每个受试者每月2小时的训练时间来学习这些技能。数据显示在第二阶段,即符号与刺激图片匹配时,B组(图片文字)达到标准所需的试验次数比A组(抽象符号)少。这表明B组受试者可能对图片文字符号有有意义的联想,这种联想推广到了刺激图片上。在第三阶段,即印刷单词与刺激图片匹配时,A组(抽象符号)达到标准所需的试验次数比B组(图片文字)少。这表明也许A组用抽象符号的训练对学习阅读印刷单词有积极影响。针对重度智力迟钝者的视觉非语言治疗计划的成功令人鼓舞。的确,这是一种向智力迟钝者教授沟通技能(读写)的不同且可行的方法。