Chang L F, Horvath J, Peyton W, Ling S S
Department of Radiation Oncology, School of Medicine, Indiana University, Indianapolis.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1994 Feb 1;28(3):589-96. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(94)90183-x.
This is a retrospective study to review the palliation rate, survival rate and complications of high dose rate (HDR) intraluminal brachytherapy in the treatment of malignant airway obstruction of lung cancer.
A total of 225 high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy treatments were delivered to 76 patients with symptomatic malignant airway obstruction by remote afterloading technique. An average of 7 Gy at a radius of 1 cm from the center of the source was delivered by Iridium-192 (Ir-192) sources. The majority of the patients received 3 fractions at 2 week intervals. Fifty-four patients received HDR brachytherapy as part of their initial treatment; 20 patients presented as symptomatic endobronchial recurrence. Two patients received YAG laser photoresection to open up the obstruction to allow insertion of the brachytherapy catheter. Fifty-nine patients received concurrent external beam irradiation. Forty-two patients were given 60-70 Gy in 6-7 weeks with curative intent. Seventeen patients were given 20-59 Gy in 2-5 weeks as a palliative measure. Nine patients received a radiosensitizer. One patient received concurrent chemotherapy.
The symptomatic response rates are as follows: dyspnea had an 87% response rate (59% partial response, 28% complete response), cough had a 79% response rate (47% partial response, 32% complete response), hemoptysis had a 95% response rate (38% partial response, 57% complete response), and postobstructive pneumonia had an 88% response rate (53% partial response, 35% complete response). Sixty-six patients had follow up endoscopic examination (1-3 months after brachytherapy). Their total response rate was 87% (52% partial response and 35% complete response). There were four acute complications: three cases of massive hemoptysis and one of mild hemoptysis. There are five late complications: three cases of radiation pneumonitis and two of esophagitis. At the time of this study, 55 patients have died with the maximum survival duration 113 months (9.4 years) from diagnosis date and 18 months from first HDR treatment. Twenty-one patients are still alive with a mean follow-up duration of 20 months from diagnosis date and 7.8 months from the first HDR treatment.
HDR brachytherapy is an excellent modality for palliating symptomatic malignant airway obstruction with an acceptable complication rate; however, no definitive increase of survival rate was observed. Prospective clinical trials are needed to better define its merit regarding survival. This paper also includes a literature review and discussion of HDR brachytherapy on bronchogenic cancer.
本研究为回顾性研究,旨在评估高剂量率腔内近距离放射治疗对肺癌所致恶性气道阻塞的姑息治疗有效率、生存率及并发症情况。
采用遥控后装技术,对76例有症状的恶性气道阻塞患者共进行了225次高剂量率近距离放射治疗。使用铱-192(Ir-192)源,在距源中心1 cm半径处平均给予7 Gy剂量。大多数患者每2周接受3次分割照射。54例患者将高剂量率近距离放射治疗作为初始治疗的一部分;20例患者表现为有症状的支气管内复发。2例患者接受YAG激光光切除术以开通阻塞,以便插入近距离放射治疗导管。59例患者同时接受外照射。42例患者以根治为目的在6 - 7周内给予60 - 70 Gy剂量。17例患者作为姑息治疗措施在2 - 5周内给予20 - 59 Gy剂量。9例患者接受了放射增敏剂治疗。1例患者接受了同步化疗。
症状缓解率如下:呼吸困难缓解率为87%(部分缓解59%,完全缓解28%),咳嗽缓解率为79%(部分缓解47%,完全缓解32%),咯血缓解率为95%(部分缓解38%,完全缓解57%),阻塞性肺炎缓解率为88%(部分缓解53%,完全缓解35%)。66例患者在近距离放射治疗后1 - 3个月接受了内镜复查。其总缓解率为87%(部分缓解52%,完全缓解35%)。有4例急性并发症:3例大量咯血和1例轻度咯血。有5例晚期并发症:3例放射性肺炎和2例食管炎。在本研究时,55例患者已死亡,从诊断日期起最长生存时间为113个月(9.4年),从首次高剂量率治疗起为18个月。21例患者仍存活,从诊断日期起平均随访时间为20个月,从首次高剂量率治疗起为7.8个月。
高剂量率近距离放射治疗是缓解有症状的恶性气道阻塞的一种有效方法,并发症发生率可接受;然而,未观察到生存率有明确提高。需要进行前瞻性临床试验以更好地明确其在生存方面的优势。本文还包括了关于高剂量率近距离放射治疗支气管源性癌的文献综述及讨论。