Nori D, Allison R, Kaplan B, Samala E, Osian A, Karbowitz S
Department of Radiation Oncology, Booth Memorial Medical Center, Flushing, NY 11355.
Chest. 1993 Oct;104(4):1006-11. doi: 10.1378/chest.104.4.1006.
Patients who present with symptomatic airway obstruction often have limited therapeutic options. Intraluminal irradiation has been used in an attempt to obtain sustained palliation. Patients treated with high dose-rate endobronchial irradiation have shown good to excellent palliation of symptoms, as well as a high rate of local control; however, these results have not always been devoid of complications. Some recent reports have shown a high incidence of morbidity, including an excessive incidence of fatal pulmonary hemorrhage. In this series, we report on 80 high dose-rate endobronchial treatments in 32 patients who were treated with remote afterloading endobronchial irradiation. All patients had endoscopic and histologic proof of tumor. Patients were divided into two groups. Group 1 consisted of 17 patients who were treated with endobronchial brachytherapy as a boost to primary external-beam irradiation. The remaining 15 patients comprised group 2 and were treated for endobronchial recurrence after prior irradiation with an external beam (main dose, 5,000 cGy). The endobronchial irradiation treatments were delivered using a high dose-rate remote afterloader. The standard dose per fraction was 500 cGy prescribed at a distance of 1 cm from the central axis of the catheter for a median of 3 fractions at weekly intervals. Treatment length averaged 5 cm; the median total dose was 1,500 cGy. The median follow-up for the entire group was 9.3 months, with a range of 6 to 24 months. Symptomatic improvement was attained in 15 of 15 patients presenting with hemoptysis, in 6 of 7 of those with cough, and in 10 of 10 who presented with dyspnea. In ten patients, follow-up endoscopy was performed, which revealed a pathologic complete response (by negative results on biopsies). At 6 months past the last brachytherapy, clinical and radiographic local control was obtained in 15/17 (88 percent) of the patients in group 1 and in 70 percent of the patients in group 2. All patients tolerated treatment well, without any acute or late complications, and there were no instances of fistula formation or fatal pulmonary hemorrhage. There was no association between the location of recurrence and complications. Fractionation, dose per fraction, and total combined dose appear to be important parameters in reducing complications.
出现症状性气道阻塞的患者治疗选择往往有限。腔内照射已被用于试图获得持续的姑息治疗。高剂量率支气管内照射治疗的患者已显示出良好至极佳的症状缓解,以及较高的局部控制率;然而,这些结果并非总是没有并发症。最近的一些报告显示发病率很高,包括致命性肺出血的发生率过高。在本系列中,我们报告了32例接受远程后装支气管内照射治疗的患者的80次高剂量率支气管内治疗。所有患者均有肿瘤的内镜和组织学证据。患者分为两组。第1组由17例接受支气管内近距离放射治疗作为对原发性外照射的增强治疗的患者组成。其余15例患者组成第2组,接受过外照射(主要剂量为5000 cGy)后支气管内复发的治疗。支气管内照射治疗使用高剂量率远程后装设备进行。每分次标准剂量为500 cGy,在距导管中心轴1 cm处规定,每周进行3次分次,中位次数为3次。治疗长度平均为5 cm;中位总剂量为1500 cGy。整个组的中位随访时间为9.3个月,范围为6至24个月。15例咯血患者中有15例症状改善,7例咳嗽患者中有6例症状改善,10例呼吸困难患者中有10例症状改善。对10例患者进行了随访内镜检查,结果显示病理完全缓解(活检结果为阴性)。在最后一次近距离放射治疗后6个月,第1组15/17(88%)的患者和第2组70%的患者获得了临床和影像学局部控制。所有患者对治疗耐受性良好,没有任何急性或晚期并发症,也没有瘘管形成或致命性肺出血的情况。复发部位与并发症之间没有关联。分次、每次分次剂量和总联合剂量似乎是减少并发症的重要参数。