McCarter Y S, Robinson A
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Hartford Hospital, Connecticut 06102-5037.
J Clin Microbiol. 1994 Oct;32(10):2487-9. doi: 10.1128/jcm.32.10.2487-2489.1994.
Many laboratory workers prefer the rhodamine-auramine method of staining acid-fast bacilli (AFB) in primary specimen smears rather than carbol fuchsin stains because the stain is more readily interpreted and yields greater sensitivity. The increasing incidence of AFB infections serves as an impetus to optimize the rhodamine-auramine stain. A total of 782 primary smears were evaluated blindly by the rhodamine-auramine method at both room temperature and 37 degrees C. Thirty-five smears (4.5%) were positive for AFB, 30 were positive by both methods, and 5 were positive at 37 degrees C only. Room temperature staining detected only 85.7% of the positive primary smears. Of the 30 smears positive by both methods, 13 (43.3%) had equal numbers of AFB on both smears, 13 (43.3%) had more AFB on the smear stained at 37 degrees C, and 4 (13.3%) had greater numbers of AFB on the smear stained at room temperature. No smears were positive only when stained at room temperature. The increasing diagnostic emphasis placed on the primary smear underscores the importance of optimizing AFB smear methods, and rhodamine-auramine staining at 37 degrees C enhances the detection of AFB compared with conventional staining at room temperature.
许多实验室工作人员在对原始标本涂片进行抗酸杆菌(AFB)染色时,更喜欢使用罗丹明-金胺染色法而非石炭酸复红染色法,因为这种染色更容易解读,且灵敏度更高。AFB感染发病率的上升促使人们优化罗丹明-金胺染色法。采用罗丹明-金胺法在室温及37℃条件下对总共782份原始涂片进行了盲法评估。35份涂片(4.5%)AFB呈阳性,其中30份两种方法均呈阳性,5份仅在37℃时呈阳性。室温染色仅检测出85.7%的阳性原始涂片。在两种方法均呈阳性的30份涂片中,13份(43.3%)两份涂片上的AFB数量相等,13份(43.3%)在37℃染色的涂片上AFB更多,4份(13.3%)在室温染色的涂片上AFB数量更多。没有涂片仅在室温染色时呈阳性。对原始涂片诊断的重视程度不断提高,凸显了优化AFB涂片方法的重要性,与室温下的传统染色相比,37℃的罗丹明-金胺染色可提高AFB的检测率。