Brédart S
Department of Psychology, University of Liège, Belgium.
Memory. 1993 Dec;1(4):351-66. doi: 10.1080/09658219308258243.
Several authors have reported that the incidence of retrieval failures is higher for people's names than for object names. The first aim of the paper was to evaluate the role of one factor that might contribute to making face naming difficult. Face naming usually requires the retrieval of one specific label: the name of the seen individual. Object naming is less restricting. First, object names may have synonyms. Second, labels available from different levels of categorisation of an object may be appropriate to name that object (e.g. trousers, jeans, Levis). Such a degree of freedom does not exist in naming faces. The hypothesis that face naming is made difficult by the simple fact that people have only one name was tested by studying faces having the exceptional property of bearing two names: faces of actors playing nameable characters (e.g. Harrison Ford playing Indiana Jones). Consistent with the hypothesis, data from two experiments showed that when bypassing a block is possible by producing another name that is known for a face, the incidence of blocks falls dramatically. The other aim of the paper was to test the reversed frequency effect in person naming reported previously in several diary studies, in an experimental setting. A direct frequency effect rather than a reversed frequency effect was obtained in the present study.
几位作者报告称,人名的提取失败发生率高于物体名称。本文的首要目的是评估一个可能导致面部命名困难的因素的作用。面部命名通常需要提取一个特定的标签:所看到个体的名字。物体命名的限制则较少。首先,物体名称可能有同义词。其次,从物体不同分类层次可得的标签可能都适合用来命名该物体(例如裤子、牛仔裤、李维斯)。而在面部命名中不存在这样的自由度。通过研究具有拥有两个名字这一特殊属性的面孔来检验“人们只有一个名字这一简单事实会使面部命名变得困难”这一假设:饰演可命名角色的演员的面孔(例如哈里森·福特饰演印第安纳·琼斯)。与该假设一致,两项实验的数据表明,当通过说出一张面孔的另一个已知名字来绕过命名障碍是可行的时候,障碍的发生率会大幅下降。本文的另一个目的是在实验环境中检验先前在几项日记研究中报告的人名命名中的反向频率效应。在本研究中获得的是直接频率效应而非反向频率效应。