McFarlane W R, Link B, Dushay R, Marchal J, Crilly J
Department of Psychiatry, College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University, USA.
Fam Process. 1995 Jun;34(2):127-44. doi: 10.1111/j.1545-5300.1995.00127.x.
Earlier studies of family psychoeducation and clinical reports on multiple family groups (MFGs) have reported substantial reductions in relapse rates for patients with schizophrenia. These groups offer an expanded social network and thereby may confer a margin of protection against relapse. However, to date, there has not been an empirical trial of this modality. The advent of family psychoeducational and behavioral management strategies provided the basis for an experimental, three-way comparison of psychoeducational MFGs to psychoeducation in a single-family format and to MFGs without psychoeducation, using symptomatic relapse as the outcome criterion. After 4 years, the psychoeducational MFGs were significantly more effective in extending remission than the single-family format, while the MFGs without psychoeducation approximated outcome in the psychoeducational MFGs. The respective relapse rates at 4 years were 50%, 78%, and 57%; MFGs averaged 12.5% and 14% per year. These results point toward an enhanced and independent, long-term therapeutic effect for multiple family groups, when combined with antipsychotic medication and psychoeducation, with especially promising cost-effectiveness.
早期关于家庭心理教育的研究以及多家庭团体(MFGs)的临床报告显示,精神分裂症患者的复发率大幅降低。这些团体提供了一个扩大的社交网络,因此可能带来一定程度的预防复发保护。然而,迄今为止,尚未对这种模式进行实证试验。家庭心理教育和行为管理策略的出现,为以症状性复发为结果标准,对心理教育多家庭团体、单家庭形式的心理教育以及无心理教育的多家庭团体进行实验性三方比较提供了基础。4年后,心理教育多家庭团体在延长缓解期方面比单家庭形式显著更有效,而无心理教育的多家庭团体的结果与心理教育多家庭团体相近。4年时各自的复发率分别为50%、78%和57%;多家庭团体平均每年为12.5%和14%。这些结果表明,多家庭团体与抗精神病药物和心理教育相结合时,具有增强且独立的长期治疗效果,尤其具有可观的成本效益。