Bird J, Bishop D V, Freeman N H
Speech Therapy Department Radcliffe Infirmary Oxford, England.
J Speech Hear Res. 1995 Apr;38(2):446-62. doi: 10.1044/jshr.3802.446.
This study investigated the link between expressive phonological impairments, phonological awareness, and literacy. Previous investigations of literacy skills in children with speech impairments have given mixed results; here we considered whether presence of additional language impairments or severity of the speech impairment was an important prognostic factor. Thirty-one children with expressive phonological impairments were compared with control children matched on age and nonverbal ability on three occasions, at mean ages of 70, 79, and 91 months. On each occasion they were given three tests of phonological awareness: one involved rime-matching and two involved onset-matching. At assessments 2 and 3 literacy skills were assessed. Children with phonological impairments scored well below their controls on phonological awareness and literacy, independent of whether or not they had other language problems. Although many of them knew letter sounds, they were poor at reading and writing nonwords as well as real words. It is suggested that both the speech impairment and the literacy problems arise from a failure to analyze syllables into smaller phonological units. The severity of the phonological problems in relation to age is an important determinant of literacy outcome; children who have severe expressive phonological impairments at the time they start school are at particular risk for reading and spelling problems.
本研究调查了表达性语音障碍、语音意识和读写能力之间的联系。先前对言语障碍儿童读写能力的调查结果不一;在此我们探讨了是否存在额外的语言障碍或言语障碍的严重程度是一个重要的预后因素。31名有表达性语音障碍的儿童与在年龄和非语言能力上相匹配的对照儿童在三个时间点进行比较,平均年龄分别为70、79和91个月。每次都对他们进行三项语音意识测试:一项涉及韵脚匹配,两项涉及首音匹配。在第2次和第3次评估时对读写能力进行评估。有语音障碍的儿童在语音意识和读写能力方面的得分远低于对照组儿童,无论他们是否有其他语言问题。尽管他们中的许多人知道字母发音,但他们在阅读和书写非单词以及真实单词方面都很差。研究表明,言语障碍和读写问题均源于未能将音节分析为更小的语音单位。语音问题相对于年龄的严重程度是读写能力结果的一个重要决定因素;入学时患有严重表达性语音障碍的儿童在阅读和拼写方面尤其面临风险。