Yim A P, Ho J K
Department of Surgery, Chinese University of Hong Kong, Prince of Wales Hospital, Shatin, N.T.
Surg Endosc. 1995 Mar;9(3):332-6. doi: 10.1007/BF00187780.
We reviewed our experience on video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) from our first 100 cases of primary spontaneous pneumothorax (PSP) performed at our institution from September 1992 to January 1994. Apical bullae were identified in 87% of cases. Mechanical pleurodesis with Marlex mesh was performed on all patients. Excision with endoscopic staple cutter was performed in 69 cases; an endoloop was used in five cases; ablation with an argon beam coagulator (ABC) was done in six cases; excision with endoscopic suturing occurred in seven cases; and mechanical pleurodesis alone was used in 13 cases. The overall median postoperative chest tube duration was 2 days (range 1-25 days) and hospital stay 4 days (range 1-30 days). Complications occurred in 8 cases (8%): 1 wound infection; 1 chest wall bleeding; and 6 persistent air leaks which lasted for more than 10 days (one of which eventually required an axillary thoracotomy for control). Procedure failure with recurrence occurred in three cases (3%) at a mean follow-up of 17 months (range 8-24 months). The ABC group alone was responsible for one recurrence and two persistent leaks. We conclude that with the VATS approach in the treatment of PSP, staple resection of apical bullae is quick and most reliable but costly. Endoloop and hand suturing are applicable to selected patients with small and localized bullae and should be further studied, while our limited experience does not favor ABC as the primary treatment modality.
我们回顾了1992年9月至1994年1月在我院进行的首批100例原发性自发性气胸(PSP)的电视辅助胸腔镜手术(VATS)经验。87%的病例发现有顶端肺大疱。所有患者均采用Marlex网片进行机械性胸膜固定术。69例采用内镜吻合器切除;5例使用Endoloop;6例采用氩气刀(ABC)烧灼;7例采用内镜缝合切除;13例仅采用机械性胸膜固定术。术后胸腔引流管留置时间的总体中位数为2天(范围1 - 25天),住院时间为4天(范围1 - 30天)。8例(8%)出现并发症:1例伤口感染;1例胸壁出血;6例持续性漏气持续超过10天(其中1例最终需要行腋下开胸手术控制)。平均随访17个月(范围8 - 24个月)时,3例(3%)出现手术失败并复发。仅ABC组导致1例复发和2例持续性漏气。我们得出结论,采用VATS方法治疗PSP时,顶端肺大疱的吻合器切除快速且最可靠,但成本高。Endoloop和手工缝合适用于部分小的局限性肺大疱患者,应进一步研究,而我们有限的经验不支持将ABC作为主要治疗方式。