Rothschild M A, Myer C M, Duncan H J
Department of Pediatric Otolaryngology, Children's Hospital Medical Center, University of Cincinnati School of Medicine, OH 45229, USA.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1995 Jul;113(1):71-6. doi: 10.1016/S0194-59989570147-8.
Several studies have described hyposmia after laryngectomy. The most common mechanism invoked is a reduction in nasal airflow, leading to elevated olfactory detection thresholds. Children with nasal obstruction have been shown to also have elevated olfactory detection thresholds linked to reduced nasal airflow. A child with a tracheotomy is in some degree similar to a laryngectomee. These patients will have variable amounts of nasal airflow reduction proportional to the degree of suprastomal obstruction. Our concern was that this alteration in nasal airflow may cause hyposmia. Furthermore, if the olfactory system requires adequate early stimulation for normal development (as is the case with vision and hearing), tracheotomy would be suspected to cause persistent hyposmia even after decannulation. Thus decreased olfactory sensitivity, delayed olfactory experience, or both could interfere with a child's ability to recognize and identify odor stimuli. We studied children aged 4 to 16 years with upper airway obstruction requiring tracheotomy and compared their abilities to identify familiar odorants with those of a large group of normal control children. None of the children had intrinsic mucosal or olfactory pathology. Statistical analysis of the early data shows a significant reduction in olfactory identification scores in the patients with tracheotomies, both by Student's t test and by the Wilcoxon rank sum test. Analysis of covariance confirmed age as an independent prognostic variable for identification ability. We therefore conclude that tracheotomy can reduce a child's ability to identify familiar odorants.
多项研究描述了喉切除术后嗅觉减退的情况。最常见的引发机制是鼻气流减少,导致嗅觉检测阈值升高。已有研究表明,患有鼻塞的儿童也因鼻气流减少而出现嗅觉检测阈值升高的情况。做了气管切开术的儿童在某种程度上与喉切除患者相似。这些患者鼻气流减少的程度各不相同,与造口上方阻塞的程度成正比。我们担心这种鼻气流的改变可能会导致嗅觉减退。此外,如果嗅觉系统需要足够的早期刺激才能正常发育(视觉和听觉的情况也是如此),那么即使在拔管后,气管切开术也可能导致持续性嗅觉减退。因此,嗅觉敏感性降低、嗅觉体验延迟或两者兼而有之,都可能会干扰儿童识别和辨别气味刺激的能力。我们研究了4至16岁因上呼吸道阻塞需要进行气管切开术的儿童,并将他们识别常见气味的能力与一大组正常对照儿童的能力进行了比较。所有儿童均无内在的黏膜或嗅觉病变。对早期数据的统计分析表明,无论是通过学生t检验还是威尔科克森秩和检验,气管切开术患者的嗅觉识别分数都显著降低。协方差分析证实年龄是识别能力的一个独立预后变量。因此,我们得出结论,气管切开术会降低儿童识别常见气味的能力。