Christini D J, Kulkarni A, Rao S, Stutman E R, Bennett F M, Hausdorff J M, Oriol N, Lutchen K R
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Boston University, MA 02215, USA.
Ann Biomed Eng. 1995 Mar-Apr;23(2):127-34. doi: 10.1007/BF02368320.
Linear autoregressive (AR) model-based heart rate (HR) spectral analysis has been widely used to study HR dynamics. Owing to system and measurement noise, the parameters of an AR model have intrinsic statistical uncertainty. In this study, we evaluate how this AR parameter uncertainty can translate to uncertainty in HR power spectra. HR time series, obtained from seven subjects in supine and standing positions, were fitted to AR models by least squares minimization via singular value decomposition. Spectral uncertainty due to inexact parameter estimation was assessed through a Monte Carlo study in which the AR model parameters were varied randomly according to their Gaussian distributions. Histogram techniques were used to evaluate the distribution of 50,000 AR spectral estimates of each HR time series. These Monte Carlo uncertainties were found to exceed those predicted by previous theoretical approximations. It was determined that the uncertainty of AR HR spectral estimates, particularly the locations and magnitudes of spectral peaks, can often be large. The same Monte Carlo analysis was applied to synthetic AR time series and found levels of spectral uncertainty similar to that of the HR data, thus suggesting that the results of this study are not specific to experimental HR data. Therefore, AR spectra may be unreliable, and one must be careful in assigning pathophysiological origins to specific spectral features of any one spectrum.
基于线性自回归(AR)模型的心率(HR)频谱分析已被广泛用于研究心率动态。由于系统和测量噪声,AR模型的参数具有内在的统计不确定性。在本研究中,我们评估了这种AR参数不确定性如何转化为心率功率谱的不确定性。通过奇异值分解,采用最小二乘法将从七名受试者仰卧位和站立位获得的心率时间序列拟合到AR模型。通过蒙特卡罗研究评估了由于参数估计不精确导致的频谱不确定性,其中AR模型参数根据其高斯分布随机变化。使用直方图技术评估每个心率时间序列的50,000个AR频谱估计值的分布。发现这些蒙特卡罗不确定性超过了先前理论近似预测的不确定性。已确定AR心率频谱估计的不确定性,特别是频谱峰值的位置和大小,通常可能很大。将相同的蒙特卡罗分析应用于合成AR时间序列,发现频谱不确定性水平与心率数据相似,因此表明本研究结果并非特定于实验心率数据。因此,AR频谱可能不可靠,在将病理生理起源归因于任何一个频谱的特定频谱特征时必须谨慎。