Imai Y, Watanabe N, Hashimoto J, Nishiyama A, Sakuma H, Sekino H, Omata K, Abe K
Second Department of Medicine, Tohoku University School of Medicine, Sendai, Japan.
Eur J Clin Pharmacol. 1995;48(1):29-34. doi: 10.1007/BF00202168.
We have assessed the propensity of beta-adrenoceptor blockers to cause muscle cramps and to raise the serum creatine phosphokinase (CPK) level in 78 patients with essential hypertension. After a control period, a beta-adrenoceptor blocker without intrinsic sympathomimetic activity (ISA; propranolol, metoprolol or arotinolol) was administered for three months. Thereafter, the patients were randomised to receive a beta-adrenoceptor blocker with ISA (pindolol or carteolol) for three months or a beta-adrenoceptor blocker without ISA for a further three months. This pattern was continued until all beta-adrenoceptor blockers had been given. At the end of each period, CPK and CPK-MB levels were measured. Of the 78 subjects, muscle cramps occurred in 27 during treatment with pindolol and 32 during treatment with carteolol. No complaints were made by subjects treated with propranolol and arotinolol, but muscle cramps were reported in 2 treated with metoprolol. While muscle cramps were caused both by pindolol and carteolol in 16 subjects, they were caused by either of these drugs in the remainder of the subjects. Muscle cramp occurred mainly in the calves when the patients were in bed at night. Serum CPK and CPK-MB levels increased significantly during treatment with pindolol (control period vs pindolol, CPK = 96 vs 133 IU.ml-1, CPK-MB = 14 vs 18 IU.ml-1) or carteolol (CPK = 117 IU.ml-1, CPK-MB = 18 IU.ml-1) while the levels during treatment with propranolol, arotinolol and metoprolol did not change from those in the control period.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
我们评估了β-肾上腺素受体阻滞剂在78例原发性高血压患者中引起肌肉痉挛及升高血清肌酸磷酸激酶(CPK)水平的倾向。在一个对照期后,给予一种无内在拟交感活性(ISA)的β-肾上腺素受体阻滞剂(普萘洛尔、美托洛尔或阿罗洛尔)三个月。此后,将患者随机分为接受一种有ISA的β-肾上腺素受体阻滞剂(吲哚洛尔或卡替洛尔)三个月或再接受一种无ISA的β-肾上腺素受体阻滞剂三个月。这种模式持续进行,直到所有β-肾上腺素受体阻滞剂都已给予。在每个阶段结束时,测量CPK和CPK-MB水平。78名受试者中,在使用吲哚洛尔治疗期间有27人出现肌肉痉挛,在使用卡替洛尔治疗期间有32人出现肌肉痉挛。使用普萘洛尔和阿罗洛尔治疗的受试者未出现不适,但有2名使用美托洛尔治疗的受试者报告有肌肉痉挛。16名受试者中,吲哚洛尔和卡替洛尔均引起肌肉痉挛,其余受试者中则由这两种药物中的一种引起肌肉痉挛。肌肉痉挛主要发生在患者夜间卧床时的小腿部位。在使用吲哚洛尔(对照期vs吲哚洛尔,CPK = 96 vs 133 IU.ml-1,CPK-MB = 14 vs 18 IU.ml-1)或卡替洛尔(CPK = 117 IU.ml-1,CPK-MB = 18 IU.ml-1)治疗期间,血清CPK和CPK-MB水平显著升高,而在使用普萘洛尔、阿罗洛尔和美托洛尔治疗期间,这些水平与对照期相比没有变化。(摘要截短至250字)