Chen J, Sokal R R, Ruhlen M
Department of Ecology and Evolution, State University of New York at Stony Brook 11794-5245, USA.
Hum Biol. 1995 Aug;67(4):595-612.
In this study we relate language differences on a global scale with genetic distances for the same populations. The analysis is carried out on more populations (130) but fewer genetic systems (11) than earlier studies. We constructed an overall genetic distance matrix that allowed for missing values. A separate genetic distance matrix was also computed for each genetic system, and matching matrices of linguistic and geographic distances were associated with each genetic distance matrix, because the number of populations used differed among the genetic systems studied. Significant matrix correlations between language and genetics were found for both overall genetic distances and a substantial number of genetic systems, even when the effects of geographic distances were held constant. This demonstrates a significant correspondence between genetics and language on a global scale. Genetic matrices were correlated with two different linguistic distance matrices: one with higher (supraphyletic) taxonomic structure, in which among other features sub-Saharan Africans separate from non-Africans in the basal split and the Eurasiatic superphylum is postulated; and one without such structure. The correlations yield no genetic evidence to support the proposed higher linguistic structure. UPGMA and neighbor-joining trees were constructed for linguistic and genetic data. The proposed African split pattern is not supported by these data. Both types of trees indicate a pattern of grouping of east Asians, Arctic populations, and Australian natives separating from Caucasoid and African populations.
在本研究中,我们将全球范围内的语言差异与相同人群的基因距离联系起来。与早期研究相比,我们分析的人群更多(130个),但基因系统更少(11个)。我们构建了一个允许存在缺失值的总体基因距离矩阵。还为每个基因系统计算了单独的基因距离矩阵,并且由于所研究的基因系统中使用的人群数量不同,语言和地理距离的匹配矩阵与每个基因距离矩阵相关联。即使在地理距离的影响保持不变的情况下,总体基因距离以及大量基因系统在语言和基因之间都发现了显著的矩阵相关性。这表明在全球范围内基因与语言之间存在显著的对应关系。基因矩阵与两种不同的语言距离矩阵相关:一种具有更高(超分类)的分类结构,其中撒哈拉以南非洲人在基部分裂中与非非洲人分开,并且假定了欧亚超门等特征;另一种没有这种结构。这些相关性没有产生基因证据来支持所提出的更高语言结构。为语言和基因数据构建了UPGMA树和邻接树。这些数据不支持所提出的非洲分裂模式。两种类型的树都表明东亚人、北极人群和澳大利亚原住民与高加索人和非洲人群分离的分组模式。