Rahkonen O, Arber S, Lahelma E
Department of Social Policy, University of Helsinki, Finland.
Soc Sci Med. 1995 Jul;41(2):163-71. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(94)00320-s.
Several studies have recently reported that social class differences in ill-health during adolescence are almost non-existent or invisible. The aims of this comparative study of two different welfare states are first, to compare whether the relationship between social class and health is similar among young men and women at different age groups in these two welfare states; second, to examine at what age social class differences in self-reported health and illness among young adults emerge in these two countries; and third, to find out whether class of origin (i.e. parental social class) or class of destination (i.e. individual's achieved social class) have greater explanatory power in studies of health among young adults. We used comparable nationally representative interview surveys from Britain and Finland. The British data is derived from the General Household Survey for 1988 and 1989, and the Finnish data from the 1986 Level of Living Survey. We analysed five year age groups between 16 and 39 years in Britain (N = 16,626) and 15 and 39 years in Finland (N = 5950). Two health indicators (limiting long-standing illness and self-assessed health), and several indicators for social class were compared. The best discriminator of differences in ill-health among young adults both in Finland and Britain was education. Social class differences by own occupation (achieved class) emerged soon after the age of 20 among men and women in both countries and strengthened with increasing age. There was a weaker but consistent association with class of origin in both countries. Housing tenure is strongly associated with young adults' health in Britain but not Finland.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
最近有几项研究报告称,青春期健康状况的社会阶层差异几乎不存在或不明显。这项对两个不同福利国家的比较研究的目的,首先是比较这两个福利国家中不同年龄组的年轻男性和女性之间,社会阶层与健康之间的关系是否相似;其次,研究在这两个国家中,年轻人自我报告的健康和疾病方面的社会阶层差异在什么年龄出现;第三,找出在年轻人健康研究中,出身阶层(即父母的社会阶层)或目标阶层(即个人获得的社会阶层)哪个具有更大的解释力。我们使用了来自英国和芬兰具有全国代表性的可比访谈调查。英国的数据来自1988年和1989年的综合住户调查,芬兰的数据来自1986年的生活水平调查。我们分析了英国16至39岁(N = 16,626)和芬兰15至39岁(N = 5950)的五年年龄组。比较了两项健康指标(长期限制疾病和自我评估健康)以及几个社会阶层指标。在芬兰和英国,年轻人健康状况差异的最佳区分因素是教育程度。在这两个国家,20岁之后不久,按自身职业划分的社会阶层差异(获得的阶层)在男性和女性中都出现了,并随着年龄增长而增强。在这两个国家,与出身阶层的关联较弱但较为一致。在英国,住房保有情况与年轻人的健康密切相关,而在芬兰则不然。(摘要截短至250字)