Portlock C S, Rosenberg S A, Glatstein E, Kaplan H S
Blood. 1976 May;47(5):747-56.
From July 1971 to August 1975, 63 previously untreated patients with stage IV non-Hodgkin's lymphomas with favorable histologies were prospectively randomized to three treatment programs: cyclophosphamide, vincristine, and prednisone alone (CVP); split course CVP and total lymphoid irradiation (CVP-TLI); or single alkylating agent (SA) therapy. More than 95% of all patients responded to therapy, and pathologically documented complete remissions were achieved in 78.3% of CV, 65% OF CVP-TLI, and 55% of SA patients (p greater greater than 0.2). The actuarial probability of obtaining a complete remission was the same (greater than 80%) for SA patients as it was for those receiving CV or CVP-TLI, but the time required to achieve a complete remission was more prolonged for SA patients (up to 40 mo). Only six (14.3%) complete responders have relapsed; the others have remained relapse-free for periods of 1-35 mo. There have been no statistically significant differences noted among the groups in terms of the probability of disease-free survival or survival, and 82.7% of all patients are alive at 30 mo (84.6% CVP, 73% CVP-TLI, and 90% sa). all three treatment programs have thus been highly effective in achieving excellent responses and prolonged disease-free survivals in patients with stage IV non-Hodgkins lymphomas with favorable histologies. Over the 4-yr period of study, single agent therapy has been associated with as good or better overall survival when compared to the more aggressive treatment programs (CVP and CVP-TLI).
1971年7月至1975年8月,63例组织学类型良好的IV期非霍奇金淋巴瘤初治患者被前瞻性随机分为三个治疗方案:单纯环磷酰胺、长春新碱和泼尼松(CVP);分疗程CVP加全淋巴照射(CVP-TLI);或单一烷化剂(SA)治疗。所有患者中超过95%对治疗有反应,CVP组78.3%、CVP-TLI组65%、SA组55%的患者实现了病理记录的完全缓解(p远大于0.2)。SA组患者获得完全缓解的精算概率与接受CVP或CVP-TLI治疗的患者相同(大于80%),但SA组患者达到完全缓解所需的时间更长(长达40个月)。只有6例(14.3%)完全缓解者复发;其他患者无复发存活时间为1至35个月。在无病生存概率或总生存方面,各组之间未观察到统计学上的显著差异,所有患者中有82.7%在30个月时仍存活(CVP组84.6%、CVP-TLI组73%、SA组90%)。因此,所有这三个治疗方案在组织学类型良好的IV期非霍奇金淋巴瘤患者中实现良好反应和延长无病生存期方面都非常有效。在4年的研究期间,与更积极的治疗方案(CVP和CVP-TLI)相比,单药治疗的总生存情况相同或更好。